为何印度至今尚未登月，美国和俄罗斯等国近50年前就成功了

Ashish Jagani

Russians never went to the moon.

And US going to moon is still a debate. There are documentaries which proves that they never went to moon.

And does it matters if we send a guy to moon or not. Its not gonna change any thing.

Instead focus all efforts on getting better satellite systems, and sending robots to moon to find source of minerals and other research.

俄罗斯人从未登上过月球。

美国人的登月行动仍然存在争议。有一些纪录片证明他们从未去到过月球。

我们有没有把人送上月球真的很重要吗?这并不会改变任何事情。

相反，我们应该把所有的精力都集中在研发更优秀的卫星系统上，把机器人送上月球去寻找矿物资源和其他研究。

Himanshu Angolkar, Patriot

Because India has so many other issues

To fight against oppressed and backwards.
Religious issues - hindutva is the only solution for complete development of India.
Nationality. To be decided only by few handful people who believe killing of Gandhi was a patriotic act.
Corruption.
Blind faith, superstition, traditions, culture should not be forgotten.
Ram mandir. For development of India
Science is bulls***t because science is against religion. Though these people will use every and each gadget and products developed by science (phone, fan, car, plane, TV etc)

8.Any person or group who is against the above mentioned points should be called anti national.

因为印度还有很多其他问题

反对压迫和逆行倒退。
宗教问题—推行印度教是印度全面发展的唯一解决方案。
民族。只有少数人认为刺杀甘地是爱国行为。
腐败。
盲目信仰、迷信、传统、文化不应被遗忘。
为了印度的发展，打击寺庙。
科学是狗屁，因为科学反对宗教。尽管这些人也离不开应用了各项科技的小玩意儿和商品(电话、风扇、汽车、飞机、电视等)
任何反对上述观点的人或团体都应被称为反国家者。

Ravi Ranjan, Senior Consultant - Cyber Risk

USA has not gone back to moon in 50 years. Does that mean they have forgotten all their research?

And BTW when did someone from Russia went to moon?

美国已经50年没有重返月球了。这是否意味着他们忘记了所有的研究?

顺便问一下，俄罗斯人什么时候登月的?

Ansh Kathpalia, Bharat Petroleum | IIM Indore | NIT Jaipur

Why aim for the moon, when we can reach Mars in the first attempt????

当我们首次尝试就能到达火星时，为什么还要盯着月球不放呢?

Rohit Gulati, Football fanatic,Loving brother,aspiring engineer. Drunk with thoughts

Bro,we had independence about 67 years ago. America had independence 238 years ago. Our premier instituition,namely IIT Kharagpur was founded in 1951. MIT was founded in 1861. We are actually doing better than them in comparison on some points. We support 1.2 billion people here buddy

我说伙计，我们67年前才独立。而美国238年前就独立了。我们的第一学府，印度理工学院，1951年才成立。而麻省理工学院1861年就成立了。实际上，我们在某些方面做得比他们还好。我们养活了12亿人口，伙计。

Faisal Shafi, Interested in Indo-Pak relations

Because of the caste system

就因为我们的种姓制度啊

Mrigendra Chaubey, harry potter buff.

First think why is there a need for India to go on moon.If that is really important , develop technologically or buy it.

首先想想为什么印度需要登月。如果这真的很重要，那就研发技术或者购买技术。

Ajit Gandhi, studied at Be in Ec (2011)

No one is going to the Moon now. Last man to step in was in 1972. Why?

All the Space organizations have realized that going to the Moon doesn’t worth the input it requires. The latest project was Constellation program (2005–09) but was again cancelled by Obama. Reason mentioned was financial.

We have so many conspiracy theories but we should ignore all of them and talk factual.

现在没有人要去月球。最后一个登月的人是在1972年去的。为什么?

所有的太空组织都意识到，不值得为登月投入这么多。最新的项目是星座计划(2005-09)，但又一次被奥巴马取消。取消的原因就在于经济方面的考虑。

我们听到许许多多阴谋论，但我们应该忽略它们，只讲事实。

Pratik Chatse, cogito ergo sum

Because Pakistan did not do it first. Or else we would have been on moon soon

因为巴基斯坦不是那个第一个登上月球的国家。不然我们早也紧跟着成功登月了。

Abhishek Batni, All those who wander are not lost.....

The US and Russia had a Cold War to deal with. They had to prove their respective superiorites, whereas we just don't need to send a probe or people to the moon, even though we did send Chandrayaan. As for the technology, we do have the tech as shown by the above mentioned Chandrayaan and are recent probe sent to Mars

美国和俄罗斯当时需要应对冷战。他们必须证明各自的实力，而我们不需要发射探测器或送人上月球，虽然我们确实也发射了月船号。至于技术，我们确实拥有如上所述的“月船号”和最近发射到火星的探测器所证明的技术实力。

Rama Raju Indukuri, Lived here all my life.. just under tropic of cancer

Its ethical to feed the hungry than send someone to moon

让挨饿的人吃饱饭比把人送上月球更合乎道德伦理

Vishvesh Tadsare

Well India must first fight sanitation, hygiene, waste management, human resource development, infant mortality, child abuse and poverty, patient care etc...... The list goes on and on....

Going to moon is a luxury that only countries that have solved its basic problems can afford!

印度必须首先与卫生、垃圾管理、人力资源开发、婴儿夭折、虐待儿童、贫困、病人护理等问题作斗争，林林总总不胜枚举....

登月是件奢侈的事，只有那些解决了基本社会问题的国家才负担得起!

Aswin Das, Philanthropist, Football enthusiast, Atheist, Car lover

It doesn't mean that India is lagging in science and technology. The only advantage of sending a person to moon is, that he will get a place in our Physics and History text books.

这并不意味着印度在科技方面落于人后。把人送上月球的唯一好处是，他会在我们的物理和历史教科书上占有一席之地。

Nita Agarwal, Knows about politics!

Yes we are behind in technology . We only copy and replicate things . R & D suffers due to lack of vision and corruption as a result brain drain of Indians happens

是的，我们在技术上落后了。我们只会山寨和复制。由于缺乏远见和贪污腐败，印度出现了人才流失，研发受到影响

Varesh Kumar

Russians hasn't been to moon. Only USA has. During cold war russians sent the first man to space so to counter it, USA lied that they have been to moon.

There are many theories and valid points with proof to support this. Go on youtube and check out the documentry - have we landed on moon

俄罗斯人还没去过月球。只有美国人去过。在冷战期间，俄罗斯人率先将人送入太空，为了反击，美国就谎称他们去过月球。

有许多理论和证据支持这个观点。登陆youtube看看纪录片——我们真的登上月球了吗？

外文链接：https://www.quora.com/Why-couldnt-India-make-it-to-the-moon-while-countries-like-the-USA-and-Russia-succeeded-almost-50-years-ago-Does-that-mean-Indias-science-and-technology-is-50-years-behind-the-developed-countries-like-USA