印度要多久后才能和美国一样发达

How long will it take India to develop as the U.S.A.?

印度要多久后才能和美国一样发达？

以下是Quora读者的评论：

Shirish Joshi, studied Engineering at Indian Institutes of Technology

Not going to happen.

Too many people, not enough resources, poor education, poor work ethics, poor political ethics.

What WILL happen is that the isolated pockets of wealth might get bigger, which means that for the 50 -70 million who live well today, that might go up to 100–120 million.

The rest will remain more or less where they are, and the poorest/destitute, which today are about 500 million, will go up to 600 million.

不大可能的。

印度人口太多了，资源相对不足，教育水平低下，职业道德不行

可能会发生的是，印度富人群体会壮大。

也就是说，今天过得好的5000-7000万印度富人，也许会壮大到1亿-1.2亿人

其他的不会有太大变化。今天印度人有大约5亿穷人，以后会增加到6亿吧

Amulya Jain, studied at Indian Institute of Technology, Dhanbad
Next 50 years would be more than sufficient we would not only be like USA but probably better.

最多再等50年，印度就能赶上美国，甚至超过美国

译文来源：三泰虎 http://www.santaihu.com/49507.html

Ashu Kumar
This is an invalid question.

Why?

You did not tell USA of when. Are you asking USA of today? So you mean to ask how many years it will take India to be as developed as USA is today? That would not make much sense as US of today is no standard and infact it's on a downfall. Or do you mean to ask how many years it will take India to be more or as developed as USA at any given point of time provided USA own development comes to a halt at that random time in the future? This is also just another way of putting the first question.

Now if you want to ask just a simple question without any reference to the relative timelines, India has already beaten USA. India has a mega successful space program with the ability to reach Mars in just 70 years of Independence. India is a nucklear state in just 70 years. For USA, well black people were still sold in open market after 70 years of it's independence. US had no space program by then.

So technically speaking, India has already beaten USA.

这是个无效问题。

为什么这么说？

你在问题中没有说是超过什么时候的美国啊？

你是说超过现在的美国吗？

是不是说印度要过多少年才会达到当今美国的发达水平吗？

这样问也没有意义啊。现在的美国不是标准，他正在走下坡路呢。

还是说，要是美国以后发展停滞，印度要多少年才能赶上美国？其实，这和前一种问法差不多，换一种问法而已。

如果不考虑相对时间，从独立开始算的话，其实印度已经超过美国了啊。

独立70年，印度就成功把探测器送往火星了；独立70年，印度就成为了核国家；

而美国独立70年的时候，还在贩卖黑奴呢。美国独立70年的时候，还在数天上的星星呢，压根就没有探索太空的项目