Did the British 'civilize' India? Fox News host vs Karolina Goswami [Can Indians Question You? E-8]

英国人教化了印度吗？福克斯新闻主持人 vs 卡洛琳娜·戈斯瓦米！印度人能质疑你吗

Tucker Carlson (Fox News host) talks about the British leaving behind ‘an entire civilization’ in India, and how according to him, Indians, till today, haven’t been able to build even a single building as beautiful as the Bombay train station.

塔克·卡尔森（福克斯新闻主持人）谈到英国人在印度留下了“完整的文明”，根据他的说法，直到今天，印度人都没有能力建造孟买火车站那样漂亮的建筑。

以下是印度网民的评论：

Adarsh Shukla

Thank you karolina goswami for representing India’s  perspective to the world.

谢谢卡洛琳娜·戈斯瓦米，向世界展示了印度的观点。

Arun Raj

I am an Indian decendant (third generation from Malaysia)

My father and my grand father praised the British till the day they passed away.

I shared their opinion as well until I read about British crimes on Indians in this information age.This is possible because of many Indians like you who expose the truth in social media's.

You are revealing the truth on behalf of India and Indian decendants all over the world.

May Dharma protect you and may you expose generations of Adharma that was done by Colonizers and Muslim invaders in India...mostly to Indian Hindus.

我是印度后裔(来自马来西亚的第三代印度裔)

我的父亲和祖父生前一直称赞英国人

我也同意他们的观点，直到在这个信息时代我读到英国人对印度人犯下的罪行。许多像你这样的印度人在社交媒体上揭露真相，你代表印度和全世界的印度后裔揭露了真相。愿佛法保护你，愿你揭露几代殖民者和侵略者在印度所造的孽，主要是对印度的印度教徒。

Ratish Nair

Wow. No one could have articulated better than Karolina. Appears she has more faith in India than we Indians

哇，没人能比卡洛琳娜说得更好了。看来她比我们印度人对印度更有信心

Visvanathan Pillay

I am a 4th generation South African, of Indian descent. I visited India.I am proud  of Karolina,for showing the greatness of India.

我是来自南非的第四代印度裔。我去了印度，我为卡洛琳娜感到骄傲，她展示了印度的伟大。

Myappa Jackie

When I am hearing and seeing tears rolled down on my chick....The faith you are kee India and Indians are un comparable you will live forever in every true Indians heart.

Long live with good health and wealth.

我听着听着，眼泪从我的脸颊滚落，你对印度和印度人的信仰是无与伦比的，你将永远活在每一个真正的印度人心中。祝你长命百岁，健康财富相随。

Ash ketchum

Bharat needs its own narrative desperately

印度迫切需要向世界展示自己的叙事

Varun

Ms. Karolina, Ms. Palki Sharma, and many more out there whose names are hidden, your efforts are truly outstanding. You stand for the truth and represent India with such honesty, integrity, and commitment that some of us born Indians are still unable to describe in words to the world outside. You truly encompass the spirit of a modern day 'Jhansi Ki Rani", Thank you for your efforts :)

卡洛琳娜女士，帕尔基·沙玛女士，还有很多不为人知的人，你们的努力真的很了不起。

你们坚持真理、诚实、正直和承诺，为印度发声，这是我们一些出生在印度的人仍然无法用语言向外界讲述的。

你真正体现了现代“Jhansi Ki Rani”的精神，谢谢你的努力

Salt And Tamarind

Awesome Karolina, I appreciate the hard work and research you put in for everybody

了不起的卡洛琳娜，我很欣赏你为大家所做的努力和研究

shekhar dasgupta

We Indians are so proud of our culture and knowledge of our old civilisation which is more than 5 thousand years old whatever ignorant people comment make no difference.

我们印度人对我们5000多年的古老文明的文化和知识感到骄傲，不管无知的人怎么评论都没关系。

Shreya Shukla

Thank you Karolina. Really wish some of our national leaders in India and abroad took it up with this spirit to call out the west's hypocrisy. For the media of a country like the US to be uneducated is really dangerous to humanity.

谢谢你，卡洛琳娜。真希望印度和国外的一些国家领导人能拿出这种精神，大声疾呼西方的虚伪。美国这种国家的媒体没有受过教育，对人类来说是非常危险的。

Invincible Rajput

History i learn from you is nothing i learn in 25 years fron textbook.. the quality of your research is on another level.. salute for your hard work.

And thanks.  

我从你这学到的历史，和我25年来从课本上学到的不一样。你的研究水平高得多，向你的辛勤工作致敬，感谢。

Himanshu 7

Thank you so much for supporting India

非常感谢你支持印度

Bidadi Nagaraj

Being an European, you have done a marvelous job by putting together various historical facts together and enlightening the hypocrites.

作为一个欧洲人，你做了一项了不起的工作，把各种历史事实放在一起，启发伪君子。

Nilabha Chakraborty

I am just speech less after watching your video. Being a Polish and Christian citizen you have so much knowledge about our India and our hindu culture more than us. It's really awesome and mind blowing the way you glorify our culture, civilization, infrastructure. Love you madam, keep it up

听了你说的，我都说不出话来了。你是一个波兰人和基督徒公民，但比我们更了解我们印度和印度文化。你赞美我们的文化、文明和基础设施，真是太棒了。爱你，女士，坚持下去！

somnath1235

U r awesome... India is proud to have a daughter like u and will always be thankful to Poland

你太棒了，印度为有你这样的女儿而自豪，永远感谢波兰

Rodrick Davidson

Thank you so much.

You truly are a Saint for defending India. May God Bless You, and give you more power.

非常感谢。你真是捍卫印度的圣人。愿神保佑你，给你更多的力量。

what is in the name Shakespeare

We are proud of you Karolina... your knowledge, strength, pride, logical presentation will leave haters speechless... India has always believed in spreading love, Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam but unfortunately that is misinterpreted as helplessness of inferior country... thanks again for making such wonderful video.

我们为你骄傲，卡洛琳娜。你的知识、力量、骄傲、逻辑性的表现会让讨厌你的人哑口无言。

印度一直相信传播爱，但不幸的是，这被误解为劣势国家的无助。再次感谢你制作这么精彩的内容

TheMobileGamer

she literally killed them with words. Love you didi

说得他们哑口无言，爱你姐姐！

Satish Singh

Karoline, you are a blessing for indian narrative . Massive love and respect

卡洛琳娜，你是印度人的福音，爱你，致敬！

HD On Wheels

Thank you so much keroline you represented India beautifully in front of those people who think India like this..

谢谢你，在那些以为印度不堪的人面前，你完美地代表了印度。

Ganesh

Thank you Karolina ji. Well said. Indians owe you a lot.

谢谢卡洛琳娜，说得好。印度人欠你很多。

Mahesh Kshatriya

You are India’s daughter indeed.. Thank you so much… Really appreciate your efforts.. Stay blessed

你确实是印度的女儿。非常感谢你，非常感谢你的努力，祝福你！

Paramdeep Singh

once again Karolina ji, you made every Indian proud of you by telling the "real" and "Concealed" truth. i can't thank you enough for bringing the "truth" outside. Your research is and will help Indians and outsiders alike to understand what "Bharat" really was, and what colonization did to us... i wish you were in the Education Ministry of our country.........

卡洛琳娜，你说出了“真实的”、“隐藏的”真相，让每个印度人为你感到骄傲。

我不知道该如何感谢你把“真相”说出来。

你的研究将帮助印度人和外来者理解“印度”到底是怎么样的，以及殖民者对我们做了什么…

我希望你进入我们国家的教育部工作

Blueberry

showing mirror to the biased and hypocritical media / media persons, exposing  their smug and slimy attitudes towards India in the garb of civilised behaviour !!! Kudos to you Carolina ji and a big applause

让有偏见和虚伪的媒体人照照镜子，暴露他们在文明行为的外衣下对印度自鸣自得和黏人的态度！卡洛琳娜向你致敬，热烈鼓掌

Deleted account

Let's spread this video as much as we can...Let's ask so called foreign reaction channels to react on this video

我们要广泛传播这个视频，问问外国频道对这个视频的反应

Lucas Bolar

She is simply previous, such a beautiful articulation of facts and figure.  She should be role model for some of the Indian girls who are embracing western culture. God Bless you and your Family.

她简直太出色了，把事实和数字表达得如此优美。她是一些接受西方文化的印度女孩的榜样。愿神保佑你和你的家人。

Joyanta Das

Really a warm heart salute to you ma'am for loving our country "India "and to be a part of this journey to get back her glory.  JOY HIND JOY BHARAT .

由衷地向你致敬，女士，你热爱我们的国家“印度”，并成为重拾其荣耀之旅的一部分。印度必胜！

Anupama Pandey

Wonderful response from Karolina Goswami on Tucker Carlson's "British civilized India" comments.

Karolina is from Poland married to an Indian. And I feel she loves India more than a lot of Indians do!! I have seen loads of videos from her and each and every video highlights about India!

I must say her videos were amongst the first to make me realize that I need to learn a lot about my country! It made me question myself if I am even eligible to think India is less than the west? Do I know enough about my own country to come to that conclusion!

I should thank her as she is definitely one of the people who made me love and respect my country more!

卡洛琳娜·戈斯瓦米对塔克·卡尔森“英国教化了印度”的评论做出了精彩回应。

卡洛琳娜来自波兰，嫁给了一个印度人。我觉得她比很多印度人更爱印度

我看过她的很多视频，每一个视频都是关于印度的亮点

她的作品是第一批让我意识到我需要更多地了解我的国家的

这让我质疑自己，我是否有资格认为印度不如西方？

以我对自己国家的了解到能得出这样的结论吗？

我感谢她，因为她绝对是让我更加热爱和尊重我的国家的人之一!

Neha Singh

You are really a blessing to india karolina di .."Indeed a daughter of Bharat Mata ". Jai Bharat .jai hind

卡洛琳娜姐姐，你真是印度的福音，你的确是印度的女儿。印度万岁，印度必胜！

Sathish Kumar Kanaparthy

As someone said "To destroy a civilization, you need to erase its history from people's mind."

For a millennium, our heritage, culture, resources etc have been looted, exploited, destroyed. Our minds have been changed and our mindsets are still at colonial ages. It will take some time to get back where it was, but the process has already begun.

Thank you Karolina for everything you are doing

正如有人所说：“要摧毁一个文明，你需要从人们的脑海中抹去它的历史。”

一千年来，我们的遗产、文化、资源等被掠夺、剥削、摧毁。我们的思想已经被改变了，我们的心态还停留在殖民时代。要恢复到原来的水平还需要一些时间，但这个过程已经开始了。谢谢卡洛琳娜所做的一切