S 400 Won't be Delivered? Indian Air Force Takes a Rs 26,000 Crore Hit Because of Russia Ukraine War
S-400无法交付?俄乌战争导致印度空军预算削减2600亿卢比
The delivery of the S-400 air defence missile system to India has been delayed due to the Russia-Ukraine conflict.
In all, five such missile systems have been ordered under a $5-billion deal signed in October 2018. Of the five missile systems, three have already been delivered. The delivery of the remaining two has been delayed
由于俄乌冲突,向印度交付S-400防空导弹系统被推迟。
根据2018年10月签署的一项价值50亿美元的协议,印度总共订购了五套此类导弹系统。在五个导弹系统中,有三个已经交付。其余两个的交付被推迟了
以下是印度网民的评论:
Sonakshi Singh
Geopolitics is the only way to make people practically patriotic
唯有地缘政治能让人们真正爱国
Aditya Talks
Every problem is an opportunity in disguise. We should take this as a challenge and become self sufficient
祸兮福所伏。我们应该把这当作一个挑战,实现自给自足
Keshav Gupta
Instead of cutting budget, we should allocate it for R&D to DRDO or ISRO or any other pvt. Co. On loan.
We can also transfer this fund to airforce or navy also.
But cutting budget is bad step according to me.
我们不应该削减预算,而应该把预算投入在国防研究与发展组织(DRDO)或印度空间研究组织(ISRO)或任何其他私人公司的研发上。我们也可以把资金拨给空军或海军。但是在我看来,削减预算是下策。
SAURAV SINGH
That 26000 crore should be given to all defence research PSUs
这2600亿卢比应该拨给国防研究机构
priya singh
Russia was confident about delivering all equipment at time, then Chinese visits Russia, later Russia says it can't deliver, instead of saying order will be delayed, as per my understanding, we need to be atmnirbhar, Jai hind
俄罗斯有信心按时交付所有装备,中国访问俄罗斯后,俄罗斯就说不能交付,不是说推迟交付。我们需要实现自力更生。印度必胜!
Abyay
Now all main big Indian companies should togetherly make a composite line to build Indian big defence equipments ie engine , jet etc and after achieving certain advanced level they should separately develop
现在,所有主要的印度大公司应该共同建立一条综合生产线,在本土制造大型国防设备,如发动机、喷气式战机等,达到一定的先进水平后,他们可以单独发展
The Aspirants
Jai Hind... proud of Indian armed forces.
印度必胜!为印度军队感到骄傲。
Indian Bhai
I think while comparing defence budget of India and china we must kept in mind the difference in size of both countries in the term of area and economy.We must kept in mind Pakistan also tried to match the defence budget of India which is 4 times in the size to it and we can see its situation today .
Yet if India wants to expand its defence budget then it must increase size of its economy .
我认为,在比较印度和中国的国防预算时,我们必须记住两国在面积和经济上的大小差异。巴基斯坦也试图在国防预算上追赶印度,印度的国防预算是它的4倍,看看如今的情况。如果印度想扩大国防预算,就必须扩大经济规模。
Shibashis Chakraborty
The situation brings an opportunity for us to look at our own capabilities. We must go for joint ventures with countries like US, France, Israel and Japan with the objective of self reliance. Involvement of our private sectors will also enhance the production capabilities and ensure a smooth supply chain.
这种情况给我们带来了一个审视自身能力的机会。我们必须与美国、法国、以色列和日本等国家建立合资企业,以实现自力更生的目标。私营机构的参与,也有助提高生产能力,确保供应链稳定。
Jonny Hindu
don't worry sir, DRDO is making XR-SAM Air Defence System something similar to S-400 ... Most probably it's first test will happen in coming 2-3 years and you can see it in manufacturing around 2030.
别担心,DRDO正在制造类似S-400的XR-SAM防空系统。首次测试将在未来2-3年内进行,在2030年左右开始生产。
Pradyumna Barik
It's the perfect time to make our own MADE-IN-INDIA defense system. Like we made NAVIC system earlier.
现在是制造我们本土防御系统的最佳时机,就像我们之前造NAVIC系统一样。
Waseem Ahmed
Currently Chinese President was on three days official visit to Kremlin, so it might be the cause behind the Russian denial of providing S-400 to India.
中国领导人去克里姆林宫进行了为期三天的正式访问,所以这可能是俄罗斯拒绝向印度提供S-400的原因。
Manali
Malaysian Airforce didnt chose Tejas for its airforce due to lack in confidence of production/delivery on time
马来西亚空军之所以没有选择光辉战机,是因为对按时生产和交付缺乏信心
Starline Cheyran Momin
Am proud that I am an Indian and I love India more than my life.
我为自己是印度人而自豪,我爱印度胜过爱我的生命。
IRATE
"Take challenge as opportunity" I feel half of the amount should be given to DRDO and rest half to MSP, this will fulfill the promise made for farmers long time ago to some extent
Jai Hind
Investing into betterment of economy is also like investing into defence when the times will be real bad, we'll still survive better being "Atmanirbhar Bharat"
“视挑战为机遇”,我觉得其中一半应该拨给DRDO,另一半给MSP,这在某种程度上实现了很久以前对农民的承诺
投资改善经济就像投资国防一样,在真正糟糕的时候,我们仍然能更好地生存下来,成为“自力更生的印度”。
HARDIK RAGHAV
As the delays are happening in Defence procurement from Russia it is certain that we will find another partner for that but we can't totally depend on West Especially USA
I think India should increase the domain of military manufacturing with partnership with other countries like France,Japan and USA.
At the end the Ultimate solution will be Aatmnirbhar Bharat in Defence Sector.
由于从俄罗斯采购的装备出现延误,我们肯定会找到另一个合作伙伴,但我们不能完全依赖西方,尤其是美国。我认为印度应该与法国、日本和美国等国家合作,扩大军事制造领域。最终的解决方案将是国防部门的“自力更生”。
bharat bayash
India should be a self reliant nation on next coming years .so govt should release most fund on R and D rather freebies subsidies.
印度应该在未来几年成为一个自力更生的国家,政府应该把大部分资金用于研发,而不是免费补贴。
Dharam
Make a similar project for Indigenous development. One should never be disappointed, and a setback is a chance for Indian developers to develop their own capability
为本土发展做一个类似的项目。人们永不应该失望,一次挫折而已,这是印度研发者发展自身能力的机会
Stupendous Facts
I think india has got a lesson that we must be self dependent and not be dependent on any other countries
我认为印度吸取了教训,我们必须自力更生,不依赖任何国家
Life at sea
When I heard INDIA...always make us proud
听到印度这个词,总是让我们感到骄傲
Aviral Goyal
We should invest this money in R&D for long term goal of self reliance.
为了实现自力更生的长期目标,我们应该把这些钱投资在研发上。
Dharam
Give this project to IIT engineering colleges,technical institutions, or similar universities with the challenge of making similar projects in a fixed timeline
把这个项目交给印度理工学院工程学院、技术机构、或类似的大学,挑战在一定的时间内完成类似的项目
Udip Patil
Every good thing in this world comes to an end at some point. Seems like this is the end of India-Russia special friendship, end of an era and begng of a new one.
世界上所有美好的事物都会在某一时刻结束。看来这是印俄特殊友谊的结束,一个时代的结束和一个新时代的开始。
Anup Sharma
One thing I notice in geopolitics , there is no control at all, no matter how smart people you put to handle it.
我在地缘政治中注意到的一件事是,无论你让多么聪明的人来处理,都控制不了。
Motivation Guru 1.M
There is a difference of thinking otherwise the problem does not come to make us weak but strong
思维方式不同,否则这个问题不会让我们变弱,反而会让我们变强
rohit gulati
This was going to happen. It's not surprising for me. We have to build our relationship with other countries as china and Russia are going closer. There could be that china had asked Russia to delay the delivery, because as far as I remembered Russia was saying that this war won't impact delivery of weapons to other countries.
这是注定要发生的,这在我看来并不奇怪。随着中国和俄罗斯越来越亲密,我们必须与其他国家建立关系。有可能是中国要求俄罗斯推迟交付,因为据我所知,俄罗斯说这场战争不会影响向其他国家交付武器。
Mysterious Stories
Proud to be born in India
为出生在印度而自豪
I'm Yours
Its too hard to maintain friendship in this cruel world
在这个残酷的世界上,维持友谊太难了
shambola
There is no permanent friend & enemy for countries future jago indian jago
对一个国家而言,没有永远的朋友,也没有永远的敌人
Chitraank Teekshana
IAF is at toll in many other aspects as well. MRFA and the need of 42 squadron still remains incomplete
印度空军在其他方面也付出了代价,MRFA和42中队的需求仍未完成
Rajan Dwivedi
This is an opportunity. Indian government can spend this budget in R&D for the same weapon we were buying from Russia.
这是一个机会。印度政府可以把这笔预算用于研发我们想从俄罗斯购买的武器。
Jyotika Sharma
" If you want Complete peace in your backyard , you have to create chaos in someone else's "
The USA has time and again proven this theory in the last century.
India has to use it in 21st Century to Survive
“如果你想在自己的后院获得完全的安宁,你就必须在别人的后院制造混乱。”
美国在上个世纪一再证明了这一理论。为了在21世纪生存下来,印度必须使用这一策略。
S.D.D
If not Russia then Israel & France should be major defense partners but India should avoid being dependent on USA for defense...
如果不是俄罗斯,那么以色列和法国应该是印度的主要国防伙伴,但印度应该避免在国防上依赖美国