中国人是地球上最聪明的人吗，为什么每个国家都做蠢事，都落后于中国

Did China people become the most intelligent humans on Earth? Why does every nation do stupid, backward compared to China?

中国人是地球上最聪明的人吗？为什么每个国家都做蠢事，都落后于中国？

以下是Quora网友的评价：

Peter Kaye

Nah, be fair, you can’t compare everyone the same, yes there are many brilliant Chinese, but there are plenty of brilliant people elsewhere as well, but overall? I guess most Chinese are better educated than most. Like I keep saying even here in Australia when I was going to school every class I was in that had the odd Chinese kid, they were alway near the top of the class, but I think it had more to do with attitude than intelligence, for when we were playing, they were still studying. I guess it helps to have Chinese parents that want their kids to be the best they can, mine mostly left me to myself, which was just the way I liked it.

never did like to study, was far more interested in things around me, animal, birds, nature, later, even rocks, ( lapidary ) that hobby lasted with me from the age of 15, till now, love it, don’t need any intelligence for that, LOL.

不，你要公平一点，不能把所有人都相提并论，是的，聪明的中国人不少，但其他国家也有很多聪明人，但总体上来说，我猜大多数中国人接受了更好的教育。就像我总说的那样，我在澳大利亚上学时，每个班里都有古怪的中国孩子，他们总是名列前茅，不过我认为这和学习态度有关，和智力没有必然联系，因为我们玩的时候，他们还在埋头学习。中国父母希望自己的孩子尽他们所能做到最棒的期许还是有帮助的，我的父母几乎完全放手让我自己来，这是我喜欢的方式。

我从来都不喜欢学习，我对周围的事物更感兴趣，动物、鸟类、自然，甚至石头、(宝石)，这个爱好从我15岁开始持续到现在，不需要任何智商，我到现在还喜欢呢，哈哈。

Richard Kenneth Eng

Well, it’s a bit of an exaggeration. The Chinese are extremely clever and intelligent and resourceful, in general, but the most intelligent?

Every other nation does stupid things because they’re led by stupid politicians, such is the nature of their “de ocracy.” Chinese politics is fundamentally meritocratic, so Chinese officials tend to be very capable and intelligent.

好吧，这么说是有点夸张了。总的来说，中国人非常聪明、足智多谋，但要说最聪明，呃？

其他国家做蠢事是因为他们有愚蠢的政客，这正是他们的本质。中国的体制基本上采取任人唯贤的方式，所以官员往往非常有能力，也很聪明。

Tomy Chang

I really think Mainland Chinese media is the most intelligent media in the world

When i watch a commentary on Chinese TV, when they comment on world’s affair they talked faster than Eminem rap.

我真的觉得中国大陆的媒体是全世界最聪明的媒体。

我在中国电视上观看时事评论时，发现他们评论世界大事时的语速比阿姆的说唱还快。

So for the same amount of gathering information the Chinese get more in depth and broader information.

Chinese system of education are nurturing nerds. Some school in mainland china get home as late as 9 pm, And I also watch a vlog of University pretty girl study preparing exam in the university study hall until 3 am in the morning, then she sleep wake up at 6 am continue studying. During my life i never seen a study culture like this in my life, i see it on mainland chinese student. Even in taiwan i have not seen this phenomenon.

因此，对于同样数量的收集信息，中国人可以获得更深入、更广泛的信息。

中国的教育体系培养的是书呆子。中国大陆的一些学校，学生要晚上9点才能回家，我也看到大学生美女在自习室学习备考的视频，学到凌晨3点，清晨6点醒来又继续学习。我一辈子都没见过这种学习文化，只在中国大陆学生身上看到过。就连台湾省也没有这种现象。

The culture of scholar

Since ancient time scholar is admired in ancient china. Civil exam was enacted in ancient era of China. You can see many Poem crafted by Li Bai, Du Fu, this learning culture has embedded in all sinosphere countries, Japan, South korea, Singapore, Vietnam. Where these countries are on the top of the world of IQ Rank.

尊重学者的文化

中国自古就推崇有学问的人。中国古代就开始实行科举考试。如今我们还可以读到李白、杜甫创作的许多诗歌，这种学习文化在所有汉语言国家都很普遍，比如日本、韩国、新加坡、越南。这些国家在世界智商排名中也都名列前茅。

Mass media controlled

Before this i think that mass media controlled like in mainland China is a bad thing. Lately i have another opinion. Even though mass media controlled has made the entertainment dull, however the popular entertainment in china has other aspect that South Korea or US entertainment media does not has, Education part.

On news section, the control of news has a very good effect on building harmony of society. For example the suppress terrorists attack news is to prevent terrorist attack spreading. It is not like government blinded the masses, the news on terrorist attack can be released after the problem solved.

大众媒体管制

在此之前，我认为像中国大陆那样管控大众媒体是一件坏事。但最近我改变了看法。虽然大众媒体管控让娱乐变得很枯燥，但是中国的流行娱乐也有韩国或美国娱乐媒体没有的方面，也即教育意义的部分。

在新闻领域，新闻控制对构建社会和谐具有十分重要的作用。例如，封锁恐怖袭击新闻是为了防止恐怖袭击的蔓延。这样做并非是有意蒙蔽大众，关于恐怖袭击的新闻可以在问题得到解决后再行发布。

Idol responsibility

On the entertainment sector, the western audiences can fathom something like a dead man living or a spy that prevent the world war, or they can worship a twerking idol.

No you can not find an Idol is twerking on Chinese mainland media. In fact Chinese stars are required to be a role model for the citizen, a chinese star was littering captured and apologized, a chinese star having an affair and getting canceled, a Chinese star having an abandoned surrogacy kids has been cancelled.

偶像的责任

在娱乐领域，西方观众可以接受活死人，或者阻止世界大战的间谍，或者崇拜电臀舞偶像。

但你在中国大陆的媒体上是看不到偶像跳电臀舞的。事实上，中国的明星必须成为公民的榜样，中国明星乱扔垃圾被发现后就要公开道歉，发生外遇就等于自绝前途，遗弃代孕孩子也被封杀了。

KokHin Lim

Don’t blame westerners. They are normal human beings. There are intelligent beings and less intelligent ones. Blame the western media and western political system that misinform westerners to the point they westerners become ignorant and naive of anything in nations the western nations deem as adversaries.

These adversaries are simply nations that refuse to to be submissive and subservient to the west. To me and most in the world. No one should be submissive and subservient to whoever, period.

别怪西方人，他们就是普通正常人类。这世上有智能生物和不那么智能的生物。要怪就怪西方的媒体和西方的政治制度，他们误导了西方人，让西方人对被西方国家视为对手的国家的一切都非常无知。

这些对手只不过是拒绝屈从于西方的国家。对我和世界上大多数人来说。没有人应该对其他人卑躬屈膝。

How many westerners knows that Chinese life expectancy is now higher than the U.S? How many westerners knows that less than 1% of Chinese use cash, ie notes and coins? How many people knows that close to 150 million Chinese gives feedback and critiques the government several times a year to improve their government?

How many westerners knows that there is practically zero homelessness and almost all poverty has been eradicated in China by 2020! How many westerners that according to a neocon institution ASPI revealed that out of 44 of the most key and strategic technology China leads in 37 of them?

有多少西方人知道中国人的预期寿命超过美国人？有多少西方人知道现在只有不到1%的中国人使用现金（纸币和硬币）？有多少人知道，近1.5亿中国人会每年多次向政府提出反馈意见，让大家不断进步？

有多少西方人知道，2020年中国就几乎没有无家可归的人了，几乎已经消除所有贫困了！据新保守主义机构澳大利亚战略政策研究所透露，在44项最重要和最具战略意义的技术中，中国已在其中37项技术中处于领先，这一点又有多少西方人知道呢？

How many westerners knows that China has a longer high speed rail network that the entire world put together? How many westerners knows that 15 of the 20 best universities in the world is now in China? How many westerners knows that almost all buses and public transport is now EVs? How many westerners knows that the middle income people in China is close to 1 billion people almost 4 times that if the US?

Westerners mostly do not know because their media and their government hide these facts from them.

有多少西方人知道，中国的高铁网络比其他国家加起来还要长？有多少西方人知道，现在世界上最好的20所大学中有15所在中国？有多少西方人知道，中国几乎所有的公共汽车和公共交通工具都已经升级成电动汽车？有多少西方人知道，中国的中等收入人口已接近10亿，几乎达到美国的4倍之多？

西方人大多一无所知，因为他们的媒体和政府对民众隐瞒了这些事实。

Bill Chen

Well, if you choose the smartest million people (or 0.1 percent) each from both China and India, nothing much separate them in terms of raw intellect. The best from IIT and Qinghua have world-beating talent, and this comes from personal experience.

These are the intellectual jewels from 1.4 billion people, a scale of humanity that’s only available to these two peoples.

好吧，如果你从中国和印度各选出最聪明的100万人(或0.1%)，这些人在天然智力方面并不会有太大的区别。印度理工学院和清华大学拥有世界一流的人才，这是我的个人经历。

他们是14亿人口中的智力瑰宝，只有这两个民族才能拥有这般人口规模。

However, there is one key difference between these talents.

The top Chinese talent, regardless of ethnicity (China recognizes 56), will invariably speak fluent Chinese, and because of that, tap into the 4,000 years of written Chinese civilization. To wield the Chinese language fluently is the equivalent of earning a college degree in Chinese history, philosophy and the arts. I believe the Chinese language is the primary reason why the progeny of uneducated chinese diaspora do so well, despite being alien transplants starting at the bottom of the ladder.

不过这些人才之间有一个重要的区别。

中国的顶尖人才，无论民族(中国承认56个民族)，都会说一口流利的中文，正因为如此，他们都可以善加利用中国4000年的丰富文明。流利地使用中文就等同于获得了中国历史、哲学和艺术的大学学位。我相信中文是教育水平较低的中国移民的后代也能拥有出色表现的主要原因。

Jeremy Hayes

That it is not only wrong but racist and that racism is a sign of ignorance. Anyone who makes such a statement is showing their own ignorance, showing that they are less smart than the average educated Chinese person.

Alternatively you could ignore them since trying to convince stupid people of the truth of anything is usually a complete waste of time.

这种说法不单错得离谱，还带有种族主义歧视，而种族主义就是无知的代名词。任何发表这种言论的人都暴露了自己的无知，说明他们不如受过普通教育的中国人聪明。

你也可以对这些人不予理会，因为想让愚蠢的人接受事实真相，通常只会让我们白费力气。

I live in China and know many intelligent Chinese people, none of whom think that being Chinese makes them in any way superior to anyone else. I have also met my share of stupid racists who think that they are better than anyone who isn’t Chinese. The world is full of such folk, you find them in Japan, France, England and I’m sure pretty much everywhere, it’s not a uniquely Chinese problem, try to rise above it.

我住在中国，认识很多聪明的中国人，他们都没有因为自己是中国人，就觉得自己比别人优越。我也遇到过一些愚蠢的种族主义者，他们认为自己比所有外国人都优秀。这样的人在全世界随处可见，日本、法国、英国也不乏这类人，这不是中国独有的问题，别被它影响。

Mark Smith

There is no difference in intelligence between the races.

Asians deal with positive stereotypes as being smart which arises from a cultural emphasis on hard work on schoolwork.

Our daughter is korean;we adopted her at 5 months old.

She did not do well at school for quite a while and was teased for not being “ a smart Asian like the rest.”

不同种族之间的智力水平并没有什么差别。

我们对亚洲人有一种正面的刻板印象，认为他们都很聪明，但这是因为他们有一种重视努力学习的文化。

我们的女儿是韩国人，我们在她5个月大的时候收养了她。

有一段时间，她在学校表现不佳，被同学嘲笑她“不像其他亚洲人那么聪明”。

We were able to get her some help and she began to do better and with increased confidence she began to work harder and her grades improved.

My son told us a story when he was at college studying to be a math teacher that 2 chinese math students were living next door to him.

He told me,”Dad, they say Asians are smart but these guys get good grades because they study all the time.”

All children want to succeed and as parents along with the education establishment need to work together to help provide the resources and incentives for that success.

我们为她提供了一些帮助，她开始慢慢进步，提高了自信，她努力学习，获得了好成绩。

我儿子大学毕业后成了一名数学老师，他跟我们说过大学时发生的一件事，当时有2个中国数学专业的学生住在他对门。

他说：“爸爸，他们都说亚洲人很聪明，但他们成绩好是因为他们一直在学习。”

所有的孩子都渴望成功，父母和教育机构需要共同努力，为孩子的成功提供资源和激励。

Hypocritic Westerner

Did China people become the most intelligent humans on Earth? Why does every nation do stupid, backward compared to China?

Those who do stupid stuff and go backwards followed western type of political system. This system is proven to elect idiots, incubate extremists and manipulated by greedy capitalists. So how can they not go backwards with all these demons in their government?!

中国人是地球上最聪明的人吗？为什么每个国家都做蠢事，都落后于中国？

那些干蠢事、倒行逆施的人遵循的是西方的制度。事实证明，这种制度只会选出一堆笨蛋，只会孵化极端分子，只会被贪婪的资本家所操纵。西方国家的政府里有这么多小鬼，怎么可能前进呢？