Are Indians the real Aryans?

印度人是真正的雅利安人吗？

以下是Quora网友的评价：

Dhruv Halankar

No they are not,India is a diverse place with a diverse genetic pallate,mainly comprising of 3 groups-african negroids,Iranian agriculturist and aryan pastoralists-And majority of the Indian dna comprises of the 2 former groups the latter one is only prevalent in the extreme northwest end of India like Rajasthan Gujrat border towns etc,this we are aryans bs is only supportered by Bjp retards who are dark skinned,have black hair and brown eyes,they are actually dravidans so indians are not aryans aryans are not indians,adopting british culture does not make you britsih similarly adopting aryan culture doenst make you aryan 90 percent us are dravidans only 10 %of us are real aryans so just stop playing this aryan dravidian bs,north Indians please stop being so delusional. you'll are not aryans but the iorny is that I have seen south indians who look quite aryan but don't identify as one…

他们不是雅利安人。印度是一个拥有不同基因的多元之地，主要存在3组不同基因—非洲黑人，伊朗农民和雅利安人牧民。大多数印度人的DNA包含前面2种，而第3种主要存在于印度西北部的拉贾斯坦邦、古吉拉特边境城镇等地。只有人民党支持印度人是雅利安人的荒谬说法。皮肤黝黑、黑色头发和棕色的眼睛的印度人其实是德拉威人，所以印度人不是雅利安人，雅利安人也不是印度人。

接受英国文化不会让你成为英国人，同样地，接受雅利安文化也不会让你成为雅利安人。我们有90%的人口是德拉威人，只有10%是真正的雅利安人，所以不要再扯什么雅利安人德拉威人了。印度人就别再妄想了，你们绝对不是雅利安人，但有趣的是，我见过有些南印度人的长相非常像雅利安人，但他们并不认为自己是雅利安人…

Vivek Shandilya

Yes. First of all, there's no ’n’ sound to the word. The correct word is Aarya. It doesn't denote a race, it simply means, the noble one.

是的。首先，这个单词里没有“n”，正确的拼法是Aarya。雅利安并不是一个种族，它只是指代地位高贵的人。

Mithun Kumar

The term "Aryan" is a complex and contested one, with a variety of meanings and usages throughout history. In its original Indo-Iranian context, it referred to a group of people who spoke a related group of languages known as Indo-Aryan languages. These languages are part of the larger Indo-European language family, which is spoken by over 3 billion people worldwide.

In the early 20th century, the term "Aryan" was adopted by some German scholars and theorists to refer to a supposed racial group that they believed was superior to other races. This usage of the term was based on a flawed understanding of linguistics and anthropology, and it was used to justify the Nazi ideology of racial supremacy.

“雅利安人”是一个复杂而有争议的词，在历史上有着各种各样的含义和用法。在最早的印度-伊朗语境中，它指代的是一群人，这群人使用一种被称为印度-雅利安语的语系。这些语言是印欧语系的一部分，全世界有超过30亿人使用印欧语系。

20世纪初，一些德国学者和理论家采用“雅利安人”一词来指代他们眼中比其他种族优越的种族群体。这个用法是基于对语言学和人类学的误解，被用来为纳粹种族至上的意识形态辩护。

Today, the term "Aryan" is still sometimes used in a racist or discriminatory way, but it is also used in a more neutral sense by linguists and anthropologists to refer to the Indo-Iranian language group.

In the context of India, the term "Aryan" is often used to refer to the people who spoke the first Indo-Aryan languages to enter the Indian subcontinent. These languages are the ancestors of modern Indo-Aryan languages such as Hindi, Urdu, Bengali, and Punjabi.

今天，“雅利安人”这个词有时仍然带有种族主义或歧视的意味，但语言学家和人类学家也开始用它来指代印度-伊朗语系。

在印度，“雅利安人”一词经常被用来指那些最早进入印度次大陆的使用印度雅利安语言的人。这些语言是现代印度雅利安语言的祖先，如印地语、乌尔都语、孟加拉语和旁遮普语。

The relationship between the original Indo-Aryans and the modern population of India is a complex one that is still being studied by scholars. However, it is clear that the modern population of India is not a pure "Aryan" race, and that it is the result of a long history of migration, admixture, and cultural exchange.

The use of the term "Aryan" in India can be controversial, as it can be associated with racist or discriminatory ideas. However, it is important to remember that the term has a long and complex history, and that it is not always used in a negative way.

原始的印度雅利安人与现代印度人之间存在复杂的关系，学者们仍在研究这个问题。但很明显，现代印度人不是纯粹的“雅利安”种族，而是长期移民、民族融合和文化交流的结果。

在印度使用“雅利安人”这个词可能会引起争议，因为它可能会引发关于种族主义或歧视思想的联想。但我们要记住，这个词有一个漫长而复杂的历史背景，并不总是带有负面含义。

In conclusion, the term "Aryan" is a complex and contested one, with a variety of meanings and usages throughout history. In the context of India, it is often used to refer to the people who spoke the first Indo-Aryan languages to enter the Indian subcontinent. The relationship between the original Indo-Aryans and the modern population of India is a complex one that is still being studied by scholars. However, it is clear that the modern population of India is not a pure "Aryan" race, and that it is the result of a long history of migration, admixture, and cultural exchange.

总之，“雅利安人”这个词是一个复杂而有争议的词，在历史上有过各种各样的含义和用法。在印度的语境中，它经常被用来指那些说第一批进入印度次大陆的印度雅利安语言的人。原始的印度雅利安人与现代印度人口之间的关系是一个复杂的关系，学者们仍在研究这个问题。然而，很明显，印度的现代人口不是纯粹的“雅利安”种族，而是长期移民、混合和文化交流的结果。

SMA Aousaf

Aryans dont exst

ok

Dravidians and Aryans are same thing

indians are brown to black mostly

so yes

they are

aryans arent white

alright

get lost

indians were never white

雅利安人并不存在

好吧

德拉威人和雅利安人是一样的

印度人大多是棕色到黑色皮肤的

是的

他们是

雅利安人并不是白人

好吧

迷路了

印第安人从来都不是白人人种

Wish Well

Of all those who claim to be Aryans in the world, Indians are real and worthwhile, if that answers your question

在世界上所有自称雅利安人的人中，印度人才是真的、重要的，希望这句话能回答你的问题。

Furious Nukefrost

Aryan as in Indo-Aryan? Then yes, Indians, especially from the Northern regions are technically “Aryans”. Research shows that North Indians contain genes from the BMAC culture and Andronovo culture. In case you didn’t know, North-Indians, or Indo-Aryans, along with Iranian peoples came from what is now modern-day Kazakhstan, from the Andronovo Culture, which was in turn further derived from the Yamnaya Culture, in Southern Russia-Caucasus Region. The Yamnaya Culture, is in fact the urheimat, or the homeland, of all Indo-European peoples, including Germans, Iranians, Indians, Greeks etc.

However, “Aryans” as in the horse-bollock “Nordic Aryan Race” theory perpetrated by Hitler and his goons? Nein (pun intended). That theory is just Antisemitic racist bullshit propagated by the Nazis to justify the Holocaust and their other war crimes.

你说的雅利安人是印度-雅利安人？那么是的，印度人，特别是来自北方地区的印度人严格来说都是“雅利安人”。研究表明，北印度人带有来自BMAC文化和安德罗诺沃文化的基因。如果你不知道，北印度人，或印度雅利安人，以及伊朗人来自今天的哈萨克斯坦，来自安德罗诺沃文化，而安德罗诺沃文化又是衍生自俄罗斯南部高加索地区的亚姆纳亚文化。亚姆纳亚文化，实际上是所有印欧民族的家园，如德国人、伊朗人、印度人、希腊人等。

你说的雅利安人是指希特勒和他的走狗捏造的“北欧雅利安种族”吗？不。这个理论只是纳粹为大屠杀和其他战争罪行辩护而宣传的反犹太主义鬼话。

Anil Garg

The Aryans, originated from India and then spread across large parts of Asia and Europe, hel set up the family of Indo-European languages that Europeans and Indians still speak today.

雅利安人，起源于印度，然后扩散到亚洲和欧洲的大部分地区，创建了欧洲人和印度人今天仍在使用的印欧语系。

Beligere Manjunath

ARA in vedic language means a SHATP TOOL. Even the latin word ARROW comes from this Ara. A person wielding an ARA or an ARROW is ARYA. Sitting on a Horse and wielding an Arrow looks NOBLE. That is why later misconception that ARYAN means NOBLE.

ARA在吠陀语言中指代锋利的工具，就连拉丁单词ARROW也衍生自Ara这个词根。挥舞ARA或箭的人就是雅利安人，骑在马上挥舞着箭，看起来高贵无比。这就是为什么后来人们都有一个误解，认为雅利安意味着高贵种族。

Asimendrakumar Dhirendrakumar Dechaudhari

This question does not bother Indians at all. This issue is not of any practical importance. It may only be of academic interest. At present, Indians identify themselves as Indians by nationality, Hindus, Muslims, Christians as per religion, Bengalees, Assameee etc as per language, Brahmins etc by caste but not as Aryans by race. If any migration took place thousands of years back, is erased from public memory and irrelevent today except if we want to start racism but India has no racism. India may have casteism and communalism but not racism or slavery or class war, as in some other countries. Migration is a common thing in modern days. Lakhs of Indians have gone to foreign countries. No one bothers about it. Same thing could have taken place in the past. All races who could have come to India have merged to create the common Indian race. Only some tribals may have retained their original race who have remained isolated from rest of India. This inter-mixng of blood and migration is taking place even at a faster rate in modern times throughout the world. Who whole world is becoming one.

这个问题完全不会困扰印度人。这个问题没有任何实际重要性，可能只是在学术上引发关注。现在，印度人可以根据国籍将自己定义为印度人，根据宗教将自己定义为印度教徒、MSL、基督教徒等，根据母语将自己定义为孟加拉人、阿萨姆人等，根据种姓将自己定义为婆罗门等，但不会根据种族将自己定义为雅利安人。如果数千年前发生过任何移民，也已经从公众记忆中抹去了，今天早已无关紧要了，除非我们想要重启种族主义，但印度没有种族主义。印度可能有种姓制度和印度教原旨主义，但不像其他一些国家那样奉行种族主义、奴隶制或阶级斗争。移民在现代是一件十分平常的事。成千上万的印度人移民海外，没有人为此烦恼。所有可能来到印度的种族都融合在一起，形成了共同的印度种族。只有一些部落可能保留了与印度其他地区不同的原始种族。在现代世界，这种血液和移民的相互融合速度甚至更快了。整个世界都将合而为一。

Ranjiv Kurup

“Arya”, meaning “of noble character”, is a trait.

It is not an ethnicity.

It is the recommended trait for kings.

Ordinary citizens may be noble but not “public servants”!

The three requirements of the arya:

They must be of noble nature

They must be highly educated in the tradition.

They must serve their people.

There is no such thing as “Aryan”!

“Arya”，意思是“高尚的品格”，是一种特质。

并非特指某个种族。

这是国王要具备的特质。

普通公民也许品德高尚，但他们不是“人民公仆”！

arya有三点要求：

他们必须是高尚的

他们必须接受传统的高等教育。

他们必须为人民服务。

这世上根本没有所谓的“雅利安人”！

JONDHALE RAJESH

The idea of a "pure" Aryan race and the concept of an "Aryan invasion" of India are both controversial and contested theories, with no scientific or historical evidence to support them. The term "Aryan" was originally used in ancient Indian texts to refer to a social and cultural group, rather than a racial or ethnic identity.

The modern concept of the Aryan race emerged in the 19th century as a result of colonialist and nationalist ideologies, and was later used by the Nazis in Germany to promote their racist and anti-Semitic policies. Today, the idea of a pure Aryan race is widely rejected by scholars and scientists as a myth.

“纯种”雅利安种族和“雅利安入侵”印度的概念都是富有争议的理论，没有科学或历史的证据来支持。“雅利安人”一词最初出现于古印度文献，指的是一个社会和文化群体，而非种族或民族身份。

雅利安种族的现代概念出现于19世纪，是殖民*义和民族主义意识形态的结果，后来被德国的纳粹用来宣传他们的种族主义和反犹太主义政策。今天，纯种雅利安种族的想法被学者和科学家普遍认为是一个荒谬的观点。

As for the question of whether Indians are the real Aryans, it is important to note that India is a diverse country with a long and complex history of cultural and ethnic mixng. The people of India have a rich and varied genetic heritage, with contributions from many different groups and populations over thousands of years.

In short, the concept of an Aryan race and the idea of a pure Aryan identity are not scientifically or historically accurate, and the people of India, like all humans, have a complex and diverse genetic heritage shaped by many different factors.

至于印度人是否是真正的雅利安人的问题，重要的是要注意到印度是一个多元化的国家，有着悠久而复杂的文化和种族混合历史。印度人民拥有丰富多样的遗传遗产，数千年来来自许多不同群体和人口的贡献。

简而言之，雅利安种族的概念和纯粹雅利安身份的概念在科学上或历史上都是不准确的，印度人像所有人类一样，拥有由许多不同因素形成的复杂多样的基因血统。

Ranabir Chakraborty

Indians have multiple genetic inheritance. All. One migration took place by Iranian Farmers around 12000 ago to central and south india. They mixed with original inhabitants came 65 to 70 k years ago from Africa. They are called ancestral South Indians. ASI. focus on agriculture.

The mixed group again went to west and settled initially at Mehergarh, Barhui 7000 years ago. Then they settled in Indus Valley till it got subsided around 1600 BCE and many moved to mainland India.

印度人拥有多重基因。大约12000年前，伊朗农民向印度中部和南部迁徙。他们与六万五到七万年前从非洲来的原始居民融合。他们被称为南印度人的祖先ASI，主要从事农业生产。

7000年前，这个群体再次向西迁徙，最初定居在巴尔回的梅厄加尔，后来定居在印度河流域，直到大约公元前1600年河水干涸，许多人搬到印度大陆。

Then Steppe people who were into Animal Cultivation came around 4700 years ago. They mixed with North Indian people mostly. Called Ancestral North Indians. ANI. ASI and ANI also mixed further.

大约在4700年前，草原上的人们开始养殖动物。他们和北印度人混在一起，被称为北印第安人的祖先ANI。ASI和ANI也进一步融合。