Can India beat China in the Energy race?

印度能在能源竞赛中打败中国吗？

以下是外国网友的评论：

manab968

Don't you think Adani is the guy who understands geopolitics linked with business very nicely and very well understands that government is the god father of the market. Like in everything India is lacking behind and the government steps up to increase India's control in the space. Adani is one of the first guy in everything to step up and build a business in that space. Whether it's solar, copper smelting or transhipment port etc.

阿达尼是一个了解地缘政治与商业关系的人，他非常了解政府是市场的教父。印度在所有方面都落后，政府正在加紧加强印度对能源领域的控制。阿达尼是第一个站出来在这个领域开展业务的人，无论是太阳能、炼铜还是转运港口等。

IamDevesh26

What China does is it works way ahead of time whereas India works when it is deemed necessary so China is ahead of most countries in manufacturing

中国所做的是超前发展，而印度在必要时才行动，所以中国在制造业上领先大多数国家

PriyanshuSingh-iu2yy

bro i installed a 3kw on grid solar system which cost me only 2 lakh rupees and got a subsidy of 108000 rupees and at last it cost me only 92000 rupees

我安装了一个3千瓦的并网太阳能系统，只花了20万卢比，得到了10.8万卢比的补贴，实际只花了9.2万卢比

mayank271288

Atleast subconsciously audience is being awared that we have to compete with China and not with other neighbours who are in financial crisis .

至少在潜意识里，民众意识到我们必须与中国竞争，而不是与其他陷入金融危机的邻国竞争。

coldram1111

Please make video on RnD in India and Manufacturing hurdles and why Only service sector startups have been successful so far.

请制作一期有关印度研发和制造业障碍的视频，以及为什么到目前为止只有服务业初创公司取得了成功。

therandomthings6933

Even opponents also appreciate Modi government with his progressive policies.  Kudos to Modi ji

就连反对者也欣赏莫迪政府的进步政策，向莫迪致敬

choosy1808

No sir.

Surya ghar scheme is ongrid scheme (without battery storage). In this cost of installing panels range bw 60000-70000 per kilowatt,  depending upon panel brand and height of panel from base. The breakeven in max 3 yr, and not 6.3 yr

不，先生，Surya ghar计划是电网计划(没有电池存储)。安装面板的成本为每千瓦6万至7万，具体取决于面板品牌和面板距离底座的高度。盈亏平衡最多需要3年，而不是6.3年

therandomthings6933

Currently in power generation thermal, coal and diesel is used.  With this solar revolution coal and diesel should be replaced within 10-15 years.  This will save environment, tax payers money and foreign forex(as both are imported).  Kudos to Modi government

目前在发电方面主要采用热能、煤和柴油。随着太阳能革命的到来，煤炭和柴油将在10-15年内被取代。保护环境、节省纳税人的钱和外汇(因为两者都是进口的)。向莫迪政府致敬！

bharatpurohit8331

12:00 one thing is for sure, through adani,  govt is pushing atmanirbhar bharat when no one want try something new which is very critical for our country adani is one who step in, I’m ok what people think about adani, I think he is the one who will play key role to built india and its growth story like Tata.

有一件事是肯定的，在没有人想尝试新事物的时候，通过阿达尼，政府正在推动“印度自力更生”，这对我们的国家非常重要。我知道人们对阿达尼的看法，我认为他将像塔塔一样，在建设印度和发展故事中发挥关键作用。

rishu.myself

We want more case study related to solar industry.

我们需要更多与太阳能产业相关的案例研究。

Talushallux1

I know of a family friend who installed a large solar park in Karnataka almost 7 years ago. The cost of producing 1 KWH is so high and the agreement they have with the state discom for purchase of electricity is so low, that even after many years, they have not made a profit. He says that the panels are inefficient, difficult to maintain, and the cost of the whole project is so high that it was not worthwhile. He has deep pockets and although not bankrupt, he telIs me that they have learnt a lesson not to invest in projects generally in India. It's a different story with large cos like Adani and TATA.

我认识一个朋友，他在卡纳塔克邦建了一个大型太阳能厂，大约7年前。生产1千瓦时电的成本非常高，而他们与国家电力公司签订的购电协议很低，以至于即使在多年之后，他们也没有盈利。

他说，太阳能电池板效率低下，难以维护，而且整个项目的成本太高，不值得。他很有钱，虽然没有破产，但他告诉我，他们已经吸取了一个教训，不要在印度投资任何项目。

对于像阿达尼和塔塔这样的大公司来说，情况就不同了。

fawadpm3826

Even though china is our enemy but we should admit that China is far far  ahead of india in case of infrastructure technology etc

尽管中国是我们的敌人，但我们应该承认，在基础设施技术等方面，中国远远领先印度

jrmahesh9340

One of the company is bharat electronics limited

I saw the solar panel assembly completly when I was an intern in it.

其中一家公司是巴拉特电子有限公司，我去实习过，看到了太阳能电池板组件。

nidhishsaliya007

A big player in the sector is Goldi Solar, it is one of the top 5 solar panel manufacturers of India. The owners are from Surat and the company is very well known in Gujarat

该行业的一个大玩家是戈尔迪太阳能公司，它是印度五大太阳能电池板制造商之一。股东来自苏拉特，该公司在古吉拉特邦非常有名

pratishthabagai7185

I would have loved if you would have included details about the anti dum case going on against china in solar modules and panels

如果你能把针对中国太阳能组件和电池板的反倾销案的细节写进去，就好了

Charvak-Atheist

We also need to scale up,

Sodium ion battery manufacturing for Stationary storage.

Because you need to store solar energy for uses at night time.

And For Stationary Grid storage, Energy density doesn't matter.

It just need to be cheap.

Sodium ion Battery will be cheaper than Li-ion battery if mass manufacturing is achieved.

(Its Because Sodium is abundant and cheap )

我们还需要扩大规模，长期存储用钠离子电池制造，需要储存太阳能以供夜间使用。对于固定电网存储，能量密度并不重要，只要便宜就行了。

如果实现大规模生产，钠离子电池将比锂离子电池更便宜。(因为钠储量丰富且便宜)

RaoSaheb-zm3jt

Overall a nice video, always have been. The efficiency of Solar Panel needed to be addressed, unlike the material as you mentioned 80%, the efficiency of panel stays in the low range of 22% ~18% in reality,

太阳能电池板的效率需要解决，电池板的效率实际保持在22% ~18%的低区间，未来新材料对效率的需求将高达25% ~ 35%。

Ronit_9977

I guess if we will work from basics i.e huge production of polysilicon within the nation, we can dominate the market within a decade as our quality is also good.

我想如果从基础做起，即在国内大量生产多晶硅，我们可以在十年内主导市场，我们的质量也很好。

ps-gh3hu

India needs to heavily invest in r&d in sustainable energy, we need to pull in best talent from ISRO, barc, iis, iit even from abroad. That too on war footing. This is most critical. We should not get stuck in little games of equity market. Because stakes are really high.

印度需要大力投资可持续能源的研发，我们需要从ISRO、barc、iis、iit甚至国外吸引最优秀的人才，立即行动。这是最关键的。我们不应该陷入股市的小游戏中，因为赌注真的很高。

jagan_94

Great job Bro but wanna add some points, you are telling these ROI using the datasheet of Solar panels and systems but believe me Solar panels efficiency start decreasing yoy just after 6-7 years and lots of defects will arise in Panel itself and with the connections/inverters too. Storage battery has a life of 5-7 yrs only, inverter too can fail after 5-6 yrs due to fluctuations. ROI will be minimum 10yrs. And after that recycling of panels will be a big challenge for the world. I being myself an Renewable energy engineer can say Solar is not a proper alternative for a clean energy, we must focus on other sources like Micro nuclear plants, Biogas fuel power plants along with solar power plants.

我想补充一点，你是用太阳能电池板和系统的数据表来阐述这些投资回报率的，相信我，太阳能电池板的效率在6-7年后就开始下降，面板本身以及连接/逆变器也会出现许多缺陷。蓄电池的寿命只有5-7年，逆变器也可能在5-6年后因波动而失效。投资回报率为10年，在那之后，太阳能电池板的回收将是世界面临的一大挑战。作为一名可再生能源工程师，我可以说太阳能不是清洁能源的合适替代品，我们必须关注其他来源，如微型核电站、沼气燃料发电厂以及太阳能发电厂。

KrishanKumar-ut3gx

This is a good initiative to fulfill the demand of electricity of the household with solar plates So that we can provide more energy to the power Hungry industries...

干得好，满足家庭用电需求的太阳能板，这样我们就可以为耗电量大的行业提供更多的能源。

aryanyadav3690

The stocks of Waaree Renewables, KPI Green, Adani Green, KP Energy, Zodiac Energy, Tata Power, Borosil Renewables are going up

Waaree可再生能源，KPI绿色能源，阿达尼绿色能源，KP能源，Zodiac能源，塔塔电力，Borosil可再生能源的股票正在上涨。

wisdomhighschool9975

Free or Heavily Subsidised Electricity for Manufacturing - EXCELLENT Ex:Gujarat,China etc, Free Electricity for Farmers- Fiscal Suicide, Ex:Punjab, Paxtan,Sri Lanka etc

为制造业提供大量电力补贴——例子：古吉拉特邦、中国等，为农民提供免费电力——财政自杀，例子：旁遮普、巴基斯坦、斯里兰卡等

avikghosh511

Mahindra susten is also an emerging player in this space

马恒达也是这一领域的新兴玩家

MysteriousElephant-vj9mp

yes we can

能打败

zenithecz5892

Only by manufacturing it in large quantities can the cost be sustained.

只有大规模生产才能维持成本。

Nooneonearth2.0

Please include the most used statement:  "This is not financial advice. Invest at your own risk"

请附上最常用的语句：“这不是财务建议，投资风险自负。”

arunk7183

Why you forgot to mention Reliance upcoming giga facility for solar manufacturing?

你忘了提到信实即将建立的千兆太阳能工厂

amodpataskar5673

Having solar system manufacturing is not sufficient, main issue with battery for storage, just like EV  our dependency on china is high as well

有太阳能系统制造是不够的，主要问题是用于存储的电池，就像电动汽车一样，我们对中国的依赖也很高

继续阅读：能源   太阳能

此文由 三泰虎 编辑，未经允许不得转载！：首页 > 印度看中国 » 印度和中国展开了一场能源竞赛，印网友的评论