USA vs China Fighter Jets | Balance Of Power

美国F22战机 VS 中国歼20战机：势均力敌

The US claims China has been stealing US technology to make their own copycat of the F-22 Raptor, known as the J-20 Mighty Dragon. We compare the stealth, accuracy, and radar technology of the two fighter jets.

美国声称中国一直在窃取美国的技术，造出了F-22“猛禽”的复制品，即“歼-20威龙”。对这两种战斗机的隐身性、精度和雷达技术进行比较。

以下是外国网友的评论：

haldern501

"we don't know much about china's fighter jet.. but ours is WAY better"

虽然我们对中国战机了解不多，但我们自己的要好得多。”

damianodonnell5844

Did these guys do any research? J20 can super cruise without afterburners since last year with their new ws-15 engines and they are far more reliable than the previous ws10 engines

这些人做过调查吗？自去年以来，歼-20就可以在没有加力燃烧室的情况下进行超级巡航，使用新的ws-15发动机，比以前的ws- 10发动机可靠得多

Pwj579

The F-22 has combat experience vs Chinese spy balloons

F-22有击落中国间谍气球的经验

SIR_RR

An aerospace engineer friend told me that both countries can build insane jets but, as long as it needs a person inside and got buttons to control it, experience is king.

一位航空工程师朋友告诉我，这两个国家都能造出强大的战机，但要一个人在里面控制它，经验就是王道。

melvinmora5729

F-22 was developed decades ago and their pilots are very experienced, us has 180 something fully operational and also the us 6th gen fighter is almost fully operational

F-22是几十年前开发的，他们的飞行员非常有经验，美国有180多架完全投入使用，美国第六代战机也几乎完全投入使用

tanjim4487

The new WS-15 is a supercruise capable engine and China has already fitted and flown J-20s with ws-15 engine. Of course, this analyst ignored that LMAO

新的WS-15是一种具有超级巡航能力的发动机，中国搭载WS-15发动机的歼 -20已经服役。这位分析师忽略了这一点

watainiac627

I'm sure there's no way this would have been published if we thought China's were superior to ours, and there's also undoubtedly info they aren't sharing here in a public video, but it's still interesting just to hear some interesting tidbits about fighter jets.

我敢肯定，如果我们说中国战机比我们的好，这篇文章是不可能发表的。而且毫无疑问，他们也没有公开分享这些信息，但听听关于战斗机的一些花边新闻还是很有趣的。

meh27143

I'm more curious about how much of the data both fighters are reliable vs. educated guesses. All countries lie and should lie about their weapon capabilities both overselling and underselling them for various reasons. As well as the fact that I'm sure chinese has more detailed info on American weapons and vice versa, but those details are never getting leaked to the public. So it feels like there's not even a point to comparing these fighter jets.

我更好奇的是，这两种战机的数据是否可靠。出于各种原因，所有国家都对自己的武器参数保密，无论是过度吹嘘还是贬低自己。此外，我确信中国掌握了更多关于美国武器的详细信息，反之亦然，但这些细节从未泄露给公众。所以感觉根本没有必要比较这些战斗机。

bf799

Oh My God! Are you sure the J-20's maneuverability is mediocre? LOL

我的天啊，你确定歼-20的机动性一般吗？哈哈

JuanMitt

Guy says that there are little known about the J-20 and concludes that the f-22 is superior... Lol

对歼-20知之甚少，结论是F-22更好

哈哈

sodazman

The goal of China isn't to invade other countries, but primarily to ensure its own safety. If you look at the history of China, you'll find that they don't invade other countries. People talk about Taiwan but even the US acknowledges that Taiwan is a part of China.

The US doesn't have the capabilities to defeat China in a head to head should it happen, despite having superior hardware at this point. What the US really should be worrying about isn't having bigger guns, but the economy and the wellbeing of its people. Being $35 trillion in debt means time is running out. The interest alone is in excess of $800 billion a year.

中国的目标不是侵略其他国家，主要是确保自己的安全。看看中国的历史，你会发现他们不侵略其他国家。人们谈论台湾问题，但即使是美国也承认台湾是中国的一部分。

如果发生这种情况，美国没有能力击败中国，尽管拥有更优越的武器。美国真正应该担心的不是拥有更大规模的武器，而是经济和人民的福祉。

35万亿美元的债务难以维持。每年仅利息就超过8000亿美元。

Foxtrot672

Keep in mind the F-22 is 14 years older than the J-30 and its replacement is already in the works for 2030.

请记住，F-22比歼-30老14年，其替代品已经在制造中，预计2030发布。

Chzt123

F-22 tells j-20, I should call you mini-me

F-22对话歼-20：我应该叫你迷你版的F-22

behere146

The reality is that the F22 has been discontinued a long time ago, one less when one is broken, and the J20 is being mass-produced. I can understand the American mentality from this comparison.

现实情况是，F-22早就停产了，一架坏了就少一架，而歼-20正在量产。从这个比较可以理解美国人的心态。

noneintel2119

One thing I do know F22's max speed is March 2.2 and J20's max speed is march 2.5.  Again I got those info from youtube.  J20 has greater range to reach.  Only way to find out which is better is to have a real fight, airplane to airplane.  

我知道的是F-22的最大速度是2.2马赫，歼-20的最大速度是2.5马赫。我还是从youtube上得到了这些信息。歼-20的航程更远。要知道哪一种更好，唯一的办法就是来一场真正的战斗PK。

Redswipe

Seeing those huge canards on a stealth fighter is hilarious

隐形战机上的巨大鸭翼很滑稽

Challenging_bias

The sheer number advantage is gonna be the deciding factor.

绝对的数量优势，会是决定性因素。

theflyer1

Art Of War - 'Never underestimate your enemy'.

兵法-“永远不要低估你的敌人”。

joshcyz

F-22: the balloon killer

F-22：气球杀手

gerardbonggo5401

The only way to find out a balance of power if the two Collide to each other !

唯一的一较高低的方法就是两者互相碰撞

IrfanKhan-nu6iu

If Chinese tech is so inferior why US is so worried about Chinese advancements in this area

如果中国技术那么落后，为什么美国如此担心中国在这一领域的进步？

calebleuciuc670

People forget the f-22 was built in the mid 90’s even if it isn’t at the top, which it still is, it is fighting against technology almost 3 decades more advanced and still wng

人们忘了F-22是在90年代中期制造的，即使它现在不是最先进的，它正在与先进近30年的技术PK，而且仍然获胜

obinnaukoha1380

So the SU-57 is not considered to be a 5th gen stealth fighter?

所以苏-57不被认为是第五代隐形战斗机?

diablosmda324

And although China’s “Mighty Dragon” does incorporate stealth features, it doesn’t appear at this point that those features are on par with American aircraft.  Never mind the advent of modern advanced thermal detection.  

尽管中国的“威龙”确实具备隐形功能，但目前看来，这些功能还不能与美国战机相提并论。更别提现代先进的热探测技术了。

wolfskid15

The F-22 isn't even the most advanced American stealth fighter. The F-35 while less cool looking and less famous than the F-22 is 10 years newer with more advanced systems. The U.S military also has nearly six times as many F-35s as it does 22s so in a potential conflict between the U.S and China a fight between F-35s and J-20s is a much more likely fight. The AirForce is working on restarting production of F-22s and wants a modernization program but that is a long way.

F-22不是美国最先进的隐形战斗机。F-35虽然没有F-22那么酷炫，也没有F-22那么出名，但它比F-22新10年，拥有更先进的系统。美军拥有的F -35战机数量几乎是F-22战机的六倍，因此在美中之间的潜在冲突中，F -35和歼 -20之间的战斗更有可能发生。美国空军正在努力重启F -22的生产，并希望有一个现代化计划，但这是一个漫长的过程。

HadeerAnnie

These materials are top-notch.

都是一流的。

sergiobowers6930

Surely both countries and others have weapons none of us know about.

这两个国家和其他国家都有不为人知的武器。

user-yy9hk9od9u

It's not even a close comparison.

没有可比性

EspressoInSpace

Why is this being compared to F-22 and not F-35? It would seem that F-35 is much more comparable in role and is actively being produced, unlike the F-22

为什么要拿它和F-22比，不应该和F-35比吗？看起来F-35更具可比性，并且正在积极生产，不像F-22都停产了

tashiyann3262

I know that both had great capability but the cost would be so much higher to the United States in war

我知道两者都有强大的能力，但美国在战争中要付出的成本要高得多

willpaddack2798

The j20s rcs is alot higher compared to the raptor. The chinese h20 bomber isn't much better. India radars were able to track the j20

歼-20的雷达反射截面比猛禽大很多。中国的轰-20轰炸机也好不到哪里去。印度雷达能够追踪到歼-20。