Can Modi 3.0 beat Germany? : Indian economic case study

莫迪3.0，印度能超过德国吗？印度经济案例研究

以下是外国网友的评论：

Tum_Tum_

From comparing with Pakistan to comparing with Germany we have came a long way

从与巴基斯坦比较到与德国比较，我们已经走了很长一段路

birajde3649

Germany was left crumbled after 2nd world war, the war was 3 to 5 years long, before and after that development was there and the people were the same. The British exploited India for 200 long years, the Indian people were not in control of their development, instead British as a ruler gave all the horrific thing like  Bengal Famine, Jalliwan wala Bagh Massacre for so long years which left people scarred, the colonial mindset was imprinted on them, to get out of the colonial mindset completely we might need another 2 generation (50 years)

德国在第二次世界大战后崩溃了，战争持续了3到5年，在那之前和之后都有发展，人民的情况也是一样的。英国人剥削印度长达200年之久，印度人民无法控制自己的发展，相反，作为统治者的英国人给人们带来了可怕的灾难，比如孟加拉饥荒、Jalliwan wala Bagh大屠杀，这些事情持续了很长时间，给人们的心理留下了伤痕，殖民思维烙印在他们身上，要完全摆脱殖民思维，可能还需要两代人(50年)。

Sai_on_youtube

So basically, education is one of the sole reasons holding back India. Great!

I'm a student in Pune, and to be honest what Ganesh bhai has mentioned is absolutely spot on.

Due to pathetic education curriculum, a super motivated person like me has now become a hopeless piece of cr@p, unwilling to do anything the college asks me to.

所以基本上，教育是阻碍印度发展的唯一原因之一。太棒了！

我是浦那的一名学生，说实话，Ganesh说的的绝对是正确的。

学校的课程很烂，像我这样一个超级有动力的人现在已经变成了一个废物，在学校不愿意学习

Abhay.Maheshwari

Brilliant video. I had the privilege to visit Mittelstand companies as part of my MBA on a study trip. The experience was fabulous. So most students in Germany are not even interested in engineering. They have a program whereby they go to the factory 3-4 days per week and to the university 1-2 days per week for 3-4 years of their undergrad. The syllabus is individually customized FOR EACH STUDENT so they specialise at 1 particular job which is probably the only job of the type in the country.

在学习MBA期间，我有幸参观了一些中小型企业。这段经历太棒了。

大多数德国学生甚至对工程学不感兴趣。他们有一个项目，每周去工厂3-4天，每周去大学1-2天，本科3-4年。

教学大纲是为每个学生量身定制的，毕业后专门从事一份特定的工作。

mohitunecha3712

I'm currently working in similar world giant from Germany and can say that it's extremely difficult for India to replicate something like this in the next 10 years. Our effed up education system is literally bleeding our society and the brain drain still continues!! With cheating scams and paper leaks rampant i think our country has a long long way to go. No wonder every single politician's kids are studying either in the US or Germany or some other European country. Modi 3.0 being a coalition government seeing any game changing updates in any field is highly unlikely! Seems like we may altogether miss the opportunity once again! The only stand out point for us as a country is our youthfulness! And maybe that will help us.

我目前在德国一家世界巨头工作，可以说印度在未来10年复制德国是极其困难的。

我们糟糕的教育系统造成社会流血，人才外流仍在继续！

随着作弊和文件泄露的猖獗，我认为我们的国家还有很长的路要走。

难怪每个政客的孩子都去美国、德国或其他欧洲国家学习。

莫迪3.0是一个联合政府，任何领域的改革都是极不可能的！

看来我们又一次错过了机会！

作为一个国家，我们唯一突出的一点是我们年轻人口众多！也许这对我们有帮助。

sanjay1901

I am from Germany and agree to most of the points, Quality here is the best, They have education method where you can do Dual Studies, where they pay you and allow to study 3 days in College and work in Company for 3 days. Real time practical study and this is across all sector

我来自德国，同意大多数观点，这里的教育质量是最好的，有很好的教育方法，可以边学边工作，允许你在大学学习3天，在公司工作3天。实时的实践研究，跨部门的。

dhanjee5790

Literally we the people of India need to understand these contents maturely. This dedication needs to be improvised by each and every citizen of India inorder to"politicalized" either than "REVOLUTIONIZED".

从字面上看，我们印度人应当理解这些内容。这种奉献需要每个印度公民，“政治化”而不是“革命化”。

anandhselvan173

In india if Adani Reliance become india top company means people of opposition criticize Central Govt. Indian need world MNC companies to manage Indian economy

在印度，如果阿达尼的信实成为印度最大的公司，反对派就会批评中央政府，印度需要出现本土的世界级跨国公司，推动印度经济发展。

gp6541

When the politicians irrespective of party leaving their ego join hands to develop the education system it automatically leads to better employment and economy automatically improves .

If they do reverse policys just for political gain the country growth will be stagnant

当政客们抛开自我，携手发展教育体系时，就会创造更多的就业，经济也会改善。

如果他们只是为了政治利益而改变政策，国家的增长将停滞不前

PunyHulk

Comparing Germany to India is like comparing OLED to CRT.

拿印度和德国比，就像拿OLED和CRT比。

kkna1002

Also, the basic comparison itself of India and Germany is wrong. India has 140cr and Germany has 8cr. Population, hence growing to 54000$ per capita, would be impossible for next 100years, unless we do some miracle ...

拿印度和德国的比较，本身是错误的。印度有14亿人口，德国8000万。

除非我们创造奇迹，否则在未来100年内实现人均54000美元是不可能的…

hiteshts

Cannot compare India and Germany. Post war Germany (and other European countries) as per Marshall plan  got huge amount of Aid and investments. access to western markets to prevent co sm from spreading.

India was struggling for atleast next 20 years just to prevent starvation.

印度和德国没法比。根据马歇尔计划，战后德国(和其他欧洲国家)得到了大量的援助和投资，进入西方市场。而印度在后来至少20年里一直在努力防止饥荒。

rahilptl639

my friend forgot the whole backbone of the argument. Germany during and after 2nd world war was still an industrial giant, such that even USSR and US literally brought their scientists to their country for their development. This shows how advance they were already, topped with mega industry that made equipment in the war. While on the contrary, India was LOOTED and made to live under FEMINE ON PURPOSE, were uneducated due to 200 years of slavery. This is where GERMANY had the upperhand, so even after the war, the country was mega hub, while here congress looted to fill their own pockets.

德国在二战期间和二战后仍然是一个工业巨人，甚至苏联和美国都在抢得过科学家。

这表明当时的德国已经有多先进了，在战争中制造装备的大型工业高居榜首。

相反，印度被掠夺，200年的奴隶制，没有受过教育。

这是德国占上风的地方，所以即使在战争结束后，这个国家也是超级中心，而国大党执政期间只为填满自己的口袋。

phanitejachowdary3

why the hell this photo is being used in thumbnail, ridiculous

先生，你说的全是事实。我们的教育体系中的大部分东西都需要重新设计。

Tearsofsoil

Germany recovery is due to Marshall Plan. West Germany to be precise. And second because of industrial nature of german people.

德国的复苏要归功于马歇尔计划，准确地说是西德的复苏。第二是因为德国人的工业天性。

srijanraghavula

I remember carrying a "Made in Germany" pen with confidence as a kid.

我记得我小时候有一支“德国制造”的钢笔，可自豪了。

msn4975

My communal colleagues shared me the video thinking that they're talking about PM Modi a dr

我的同事给我分享了这个，他们都说莫迪总理是独 裁者

pritishpatil7659

One important point missed here, which can be the topic for next video: Demand problem of India. Most Indians never buy quality products, we always go for cheap ones. Cheap quality products are a lose lose for everyone:

漏掉了一个要点：印度的需求问题。大多数印度人从不买高质量的产品，我们总是买便宜的东西。

abhilashreddy9548

We already lost the battle as  quality of our  government education system is in 3rd class standards, how can we expect to deliver quality in products we make, if our thinking system is 3 rd class? Don’t get it wrong think about it twice. Germans are strict about timings, rules, delivery and service the value of which they have been taught from young age!  We can’t make a full grown tree to bend but a growing tree.

我们已经输掉了这场战争，我们的教育体系的质量是三流的。我们的思维体系是三流的，我们怎么能期望我们生产的产品质量有多高呢？

别搞错了，再考虑一下。德国人对时间、规则、交付和服务都很严格，他们从小就被灌输这些价值观！

我们不能让一棵长得高耸入云的大树弯曲，只能让一棵正在生长的树弯曲。

PrabhatDoongarwal

Only if we didn't have to spend on defence like Germany. Just being part of EU uplifts you. Not a fair competition.

除非我们像德国那样不必在国防上花钱，欧盟也能带来优势。这样的竞争是不公平的。

deeprahangdale453

Despite being aware of the problems we face and knowing the solutions to them, we often fail to take the necessary steps to overcome them.

尽管我们意识到所面临的问题，也知道解决问题的办法，但我们未能采取措施解决问题。

hemanathan.e

We are doomed because of incompetency of government sectors to be honest. We need major revolution of government sectors with highly functioning system that doesn’t require any one to run. In that way we can reduce corruption and disciplinary issues. Until then we are doomed to be mediocre

由于政府部门的无能，我们注定要失败。我们需要对政府部门进行重大改革，建立一个不需要任何人来运行的高功能系统。

这样我们就可以减少腐败，解决纪律问题。在那之前，我们注定碌碌无为。

motivation_geek581

Loved the video man. I cannot even fathom how much research would your team needs to do, to create such insightful and knowledgeful videos. Keep creating bro so that I and many more teenagers can learn more and more from these videos

至于教育，这是领导人最不关心的事情，因为受过教育的人口有主见，不好忽悠。

ritam378

This video is a goldmine... I hope the msg reached the govt of india.

这个内容是宝藏，希望印度政府能看到。

royd4669

I am working in germany and this is best video on how germany works. German Education system is the best example of  how Industrial collaboration creates High Quality Education.

我在德国工作。德国教育体系是产业合作创造高质量教育的最佳范例。

ganeshreddykomitireddy5128

If there is anybody here who is from a political background or the people working in the Government itself, they would better take these suggestions to the higher officials to bring them into action.

如果在座的各位有政治背景或在政府工作，最好把这些建议向上级反映，并付诸实施。