Why Indian Immigrants Are Richer Than Chinese Despite Similar Hard Work?

一样努力工作，为什么印度移民比中国移民更富有

Despite the well-known fact that China is far ahead of India in terms of development, advancement, living standards, and economy, Indian immigrants often find greater success and wealth than their Chinese counterparts. This might seem surprising given China's global economic prowess. Generally, both Indian and Chinese immigrants achieve remarkable success abroad, more so than in their homelands. This trend is common among many Asians, including Filipinos, Pakistanis, and Koreans. However, when comparing Indian and Chinese immigrants, several key factors tend to favor Indians. Even though both groups share ancient civilizations, strong family values, and a focus on higher education and hard work, Indians benefit from specific advantages that Chinese immigrants don’t always have.

众所周知，中国经济发展、社会进步和生活水平都远远领先于印度，但印度移民在海外往往比中国移民获得更大的成功，积累更多的财富。

考虑到中国的全球经济实力，这似乎令人惊讶。总的来说，印度移民和中国移民在国外都取得了显著的成功，比在自己的祖国更成功。

这种趋势在菲律宾、巴基斯坦、韩国等亚洲国家也很普遍。然而，当比较印度移民和中国移民时，有几个关键因素倾向于印度人。

尽管这两个群体都有着古老的文明，强烈的家庭价值观，都注重高等教育和努力工作，但印度人受益于中国移民所不具备的特定优势。

​

以下是外国网友的评论：

georgeloh8257

Generally, East Asians are introverts, they talk less but can deliver excellent results ( for examples: Nvidea, AMD and Broadcom ).

总体来说，东亚人内向，话少，但能力出众。

induchopra3014

They are cream of india. Top brains. Not ordinary  indians. No wonder they do well. They are used to competition.

他们是印度的精英，高智商，不是普通的印度人。他们很成功，习惯竞争。

anetavaid5485

Chinese people don't flaunt their wealth.

Indians do.

中国人不炫富，而印度人炫富。

teohsoonkeat3058

Chinese are too smart..........many are humble........and behave simple.....

中国人太聪明了，而且很谦虚。

VChong1991

Carl zha made a point about this. Indians are more outspoken a trait only the west value. We do things differently so western corporations wont put us in charge as they see our passive method as weakness. But results show, china is outshinng the west.

印度人更直言不讳，西方看重这一点。我们做事方式不同，西方公司不会让我们担任主要岗位，他们认为我们做事比较被动，这是弱点。但结果显示，中国正在超越西方。

randyhuy2889

Rich or poor no matter.  Just work hard to improve people everywhere.

无论贫富，只要努力工作，改善生活就行。

brianwood4128

Look at Malaysia, 10 richest person. 9 is Chinese, only 1 is Indian.

看看马来西亚，10位最富有的人，9个是华人，只有1个是印度裔。

PA-hf7gy

Chinese people in Hongkong, Taiwan and Singapore are rich.

中国香港、中国台湾和新加坡人很富。

henrymac506

India's egos are way of the charts

印度人的自尊心非常强

keangwooichoo6138

Indians and chinese have great civilisation. Both influenced south east asia. Before islam arrive in south east asia.

印度人和中国人有伟大的文明。在ysl教传入东南亚之前，两者都影响了东南亚

shermanpeabody6102

The ability to speak English is a double-edge sword.

Almost all call center scams are done in English.  Almost all the victims of scam calls reside in U.S. and UK.

According to Jim Browning, 95% of scam calls originate from India.

英语能力是一把双刃剑。

几乎所有的呼叫中心打出的诈骗电话都是说英语的。几乎所有诈骗电话的受害者都居住在美国和英国。据吉姆·布朗宁(Jim Browning)称，95%的诈骗电话是从印度打出的。

mekonnenhaile4148

western countries trust Indians because of political reasoning as well. Chinese are also less flexble and more royal to their original country

西方国家信任印度人也是出于政治原因。中国人也没有那么灵活，对自己的祖国更加忠诚

NCM-xy8ow

Indians by and  large prefer to be professionals and work for western companies or organizations. Not so much for many Chinese

总的来说，印度人更喜欢成为专业人士，为西方公司或组织工作，而很多中国人并非如此

pradeeptiwari1377

indian are hard worker that’s the fact.

印度人工作很努力，这是事实。

Neeleish_cr_gaawre

You only talked about english proficiency of indians but you forget or you lack knowledge about indian IIT(INDIAN  INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY) where almost all the ceo and politician studied there

你只谈到了印度人的英语能力，但你忘了印度理工学院或者对这个学校不了解，几乎所有的首席执行官和政治家都是这个学校出来的

timfoo8337

The last statement in this clip is poignant. It stems from the fact that much more Indian top professionals  became US citizens, and remained in USA, compared to Chinese. To India, it is a brain drain.

最后一句话令人心酸。这源于这样一个事实，与中国人相比，更多的印度顶级专业人士成为美国公民，并留在美国。对印度来说，这是人才流失。

​

user-kp5wi8qy8c

What about the Filipino?

那菲律宾人呢?

simplerway489

India sends their best and brightest to the US.  

印度把最优秀、最聪明的人才送到了美国。

kkrkkr3531

Very simple reason some come with dream, passion and vision. They are very clear about what they want to achieve. Not all indians become so rich . Some have become so u call them indians.

they do not even have indian citizenship now.

原因很简单，有些人带着梦想、激情和愿景而来。他们非常清楚自己想要达到的目标。并非所有印度人都能富起来的，有些你所说的印度人，现在甚至没有印度公民身份。

linmux

These all owe to curry the superfood

这些都归功于咖喱这种超级食物

teohsoonkeat3058

Chinese believes in savings.......and simple life.............

中国人爱存钱，生活简单

szavadya

Why are you finding excuses ? Why can't you just admit Indian genetics is smarter than rest ?

为什么要找借口？为什么就不能承认印度人就是比其他人聪明呢？

​

guytruth5598

Why you fellow always like to compare any single thing with the Chinese. The Chinese just care less about what the Indian do.

为什么你们这些家伙总是喜欢和中国人比。中国人根本不关心印度人做什么。

jhonlie5460

Indian more likely employ by others the chin more likely independent doing themselves

印度人更有可能被别人雇佣，而中国人更有可能自主创业

sushilpandey4408

Chinese are more nationalists than Indians and love for the motherland is more with Chinese than Indians. Indians like to speak openly against their motherland not the Chinese. So Indians are more open and quickly adapt to alien culture not so with the Chinese.

中国人比印度人更民族主义，比印度人更爱祖国。

印度人喜欢公开反对他们的祖国，而中国人不会这样做。所以印度人更开放，能很快适应外来文化，而中国人却不是这样。

tswong2409

Why all country feel jealousy of Mighty China.. Dislike China do not visit China, talk rubbish no 1..

为什么所有国家都嫉妒强大的中国，不喜欢中国，不要去中国，全是废话…

DLAM19

Chinese tend to be more loyal to their country, Indian just want to get out of India!

中国人更忠于自己的国家，而印度人只想离开自己的国家

MrPoornakumar

Because India lags behind in Technology (compared to PRC) many Indians with higher qualifications in Technology find it easier (and lucrative) to move to America. At one time, it appeared so, that India's IITs produce post-graduates in technology, for jobs  waiting in America.

与中国相比，由于印度在技术上落后，许多掌握先进技术的印度人发现移居美国更容易，也更有利可图。有一段时间，似乎是这样，印度理工学院培养的技术研究生，排着队去美国工作。

anuj_s_world

Chinese people stay in the technical side they don't take management jobs. Chinese are more tech savy than Indians. Plus lot of Indians are also entrepreneurs, Chinese on the other have don't do a lot of start-ups in the tech industry.

中国人从事技术方面的工作，不从事管理工作。中国人比印度人更懂技术。另外，很多印度人也是企业家，另一方面，中国人在科技行业没有很多创业公司。

nicb.1213

The Chinese Scientists work for their nations and the Indians work for monies and personal interest.  With this culture India growth is either at status quo or decline.

中国科学家为国家工作，而印度科学家工作是为了钱和个人利益。在这种文化下，印度的增长要么保持现状，要么下降。

ptaing8

India has the world largest population and win zero gold in Paris 2024. Almost all billioniars in South East Asia are Han people (Chinese).

印度拥有世界上最多的人口，但在2024年巴黎奥运会上一枚金牌都没拿到。东南亚几乎所有的亿万富翁都是华人