Trump vs. Harris: Who's Better for the US Economy?

特朗普 vs哈里斯：谁当选对美国经济更有利？

As the 2024 US Presidential Election approaches, voters are split on economic issues. Kamala Harris promises an "opportunity economy" focused on targeted tax cuts, healthcare reform, and green energy. Meanwhile, Donald Trump is pushing for tax reductions, especially for American-made products, and a tariff-heavy trade policy. In this video, we dive into each candidate's economic plan, compare their records, and analyze decades of data showing how U.S. economies fared under both Republican and Democratic leadership. With the world watching, the question is: who do Americans trust more with their financial future?

2024年美国总统大选临近，选民们在经济问题上存在分歧。卡玛拉·哈里誓言打造“机会经济”，重点是有针对性的减税、医疗改革和绿色能源。

与此同时，唐纳德·特朗普正在推动减税，特别是对美国制造的产品，以及一项重关税的贸易政策。

深入研究每位候选人的经济计划，比较了他们的记录，并分析几十年来美国经济在共和党和民 主党领导下的表现。

在全世界的关注下，问题是：美国人会更信任谁？

以下是外国网友的评论：

JosephHoggang-bk4bk

Do not underestimate the power of ignorance during election.

在选举中不要低估无知的力量。

jeremytine

The biggest fallacy is that the President can steer the economy like a CEO steers a company. They simply don't have that  kind of influence. There are alot of factors and congress arguably plays a bigger part.

最大的谬论是，总统可以像首席执行官操纵公司一样操纵经济。他们根本没有那种影响力。有很多因素，可以说国会发挥了更大的作用。

colintclai

Sadly people tend to ignore facts but listen to demagogues and populists.

可悲的是，人们倾向于忽视事实，听信煽动者和民粹主义者的话。

lamduxuan5806

When economists try to speak up

经济学家试图发声

tysonreuter5788

Just because Germany’s economy is circling the shitter doesn’t mean the U.S. economy is doing great. Only by comparison.

仅仅因为德国经济陷入困境并不意味着美国经济表现良好，只能通过比较才能下结论。

jasonmarriott1058

Well considering that most of Trumps merch is produced in China.. hmmmm....

特朗普的大部分商品都是在中国生产的，所以……

alystero8838

Polls showed Hillary would win by a majority

民调显示希拉里将以多数票获胜

aidegdev

In this world of lies, people never, no matter what happen, understand nothing.............

在这个充满谎言的世界里，不管发生什么事，人们永远不会理解.............

wazgood100

They forgot to mention Trump said no tax on overtime and no tax on social security benefits!

他们忘了提特朗普说了加班费不征税，社会保障福利不征税！

guavaburst

'No tax on tips' because business owners will own the tips, not the staff member.

“小费不征税”，因为小费归老板，而不是员工。

AbsolutelyFabulous3

Oops, I voted Trump

我投给了特朗普

denob1297

What exactly is she talking about an opportunity economy. I always heard that this is the land of opportunity. I was always told in school I have the opportunity to run or be president if I want it. So, I ask what exactly is an opportunity economy if we're already in an opportunity country.

她说的机会经济到底是什么。我总是听说这是一片充满机会的土地。在学校里，我总是被告知，如果我想，我也有机会竞选或成为总统。

所以，我想问，如果我们已经是一个机会国家，那机会经济到底是什么？

nfwlpw

The congress also has a large effect on the economy, especially the deficit.

国会对经济也有很大的影响，尤其是对赤字。

adamalrashid9044

I honestly don’t know who would be great for economy!

老实说，我不知道谁对经济更有利！

dral9657

We saw trump destroy the economic growth of a 15 steady climb !

我们看到特朗普摧毁了稳步攀升的经济增长！

frederickrose3967

How is the press even treating this as a serious question at this point????

媒体怎么能把这当成一个严肃的问题？

HamletOfNorway

Ask the question to Elon Musk.

这个问题问问埃隆·马斯克吧。

alvinvazha1144

As far as I understand,  Trump wants the US to withdraw from international affairs, which eventually will boost their economy. But it comes at a cost of losing influence on the global stage.

据我所知，特朗普希望美国退出国际事务，这最终会促进美国的经济。但这是以在全球舞台上失去影响力为代价的。

MrMbergner

For the rich elite, inflation isn’t a big deal I guess.  Must be nice.

我想，对于富有的精英阶层来说，通货膨胀不是什么大问题。

Lucas-wn5wm

Market is great currently? Why are there  job cuts?

目前市场很好？那为什么要裁员？

p-jaycalabazaron2650

Past performance does not guarantee future performance. This video is very skewed towards de ocrats.

过去的表现不能保证未来的表现。这是明显偏向民 主党。

gfs263

GERMANY IS AFRAID OF TRUMP TAXES

德国害怕特朗普加税

sleepy_dobe

Just curious, is there a similar comparison statistic showing the difference in earnings/asset value/wealth of the top 5% - 10% of Americans under a president from the two different parties?

只是好奇，有没有类似的比较统计数据显示，在来自两个不同政党的总统领导下，收入最高的5%-10%的美国人在收入、资产价值和财富方面的差异？

398robin

There are more well to do people who are making money on our stock market. But the people who are living paycheck to paycheck are having a hard time to pay the high prices of groceries, gas, insurance, cars, and homes. Some people are even maxng out their credit cards because they are falling behind in their payments. It is the inflation from our government overspending that is taxng our people’s ability to pay their bills. It will be hard to endure another four years of Democrat mismanagement if Harris wins. If Trump wins, the elites will attack him like they did when he was President. Pray for freedom with Trump and not co sm with Harris.

有钱人在我们的股票市场上赚钱。但是那些靠薪水过日子的人却很难支付高昂的食品杂货、汽油、保险、汽车和住房支出。

有些人甚至因为拖欠贷款而刷爆了信用卡。正是我们的政府过度支出造成的通货膨胀，使我们的人民无力支付他们的账单。

如果哈里斯获胜，人们很难再忍受民 主党四年的管理不善。

如果特朗普赢了，精英们会像他上个总统任期时那样攻击他。祈祷特朗普赢，而不是哈里斯！

letoolee3570

yes, economy doing well, does not totally means people are living well, and also every economy policy have a long term effect, Democarts's period have a better GDP number do not means they are doing well and holding the right policy, sometime, just the oppisite.

经济表现良好，并不完全意味着人们生活得好，而且每一项经济政策都有长期影响，民 主党时期GDP数据更亮眼，并不意味着他们做得好，并不意味他们的政策是合理的，有时，恰恰相反。

Voxabonable

Neither of them are good for humankind, let alone economy.

二者对人类都没有好处，更不用说经济了。

angela-ji1cg

I just don't know & I have to send in my vote tomorrow.

不知道，我明天必须得投票了。

headsuphockeypodcast2707

I voted for Harris. Trump wants to give tax breaks to the wealthy

我投了哈里斯。特朗普想给富人减税