Why is India not a Nuclear Superpower ? | Geopolitical Case Study

地缘政治案例研究：为什么印度不是核超级大国？

以下是印度网友的评论：

surajkumar5182

Not just Homi Bhabha but more than 11 Indian nuclear scientists have died Mysterious death we all are too busy in our internal conflicts so much that some western powers are secretly paralyzing our country for decades

不仅仅是霍米·巴巴，超过11名印度核科学家已经死亡。离奇死亡。我们内讧严重，被一些西方大国钻了空子，秘密瘫痪了我们国家几十年

JSnwl-ng5zq

Everyone today is like "Soviet helped India in 1971, we are true brother's" but we must realise that it was in Soveit union where shastri ji died. If he had not died we could have achieved Nuclear bomb before 1971 war. If we had nuke then no country would have dared to attack India and we wouldn't have needed USSR for help in the first place.

今天每个人都在说“苏联在1971年帮助了印度，我们是真正的兄弟”，但我们必须意识到，夏斯特里是在苏联去世的。

如果他没有死，我们可以在1971年战争前造出核弹。如果我们有核武器，那么没有国家敢攻击印度，我们一开始就不需要苏联的帮助了。

Ronit_9977

Don't know how much blood shed is there in our history. Many sacrificed themselves for us, but are unknown. I hope, we will make the dreams of Sir Bhabha true soon and make India a roaring golden lion. Jai Bharat .

不知道我们的历史上有多少流血事件。很多人为国家牺牲了自己，却不为人知。

我希望，我们能尽快实现巴巴先生的梦想，让印度成为咆哮的金狮。印度必胜！

IAmOxdised7525

CIA killed Homi Bhabha , Shastri by ISI

CIA杀了霍米·巴巴， ISI杀了夏斯特里

sahilparmar148

I wrote an article for our college's annual magazine with same title "India's Nuclear Program" just 2-3 months ago......

就在2-3个月前，我为我们学院的年度杂志写了一篇题为“印度的核计划”的文章.......

Laxmanca

if indian government starts giving more attention and focus on our scientists,

trust me our nation can really boost in technology and efforts and hardwork Indian peoples give towards their passion/profession

is mindblowing, but what  they are getting back towards services is so undercasted till !

如果印度政府开始多关注我们的科学家，我们的国家真的可以在技术上取得进步，他们愿意付出努力。但他们的服务得到的回报是如此低！

getexplainedone

The word hero is for people like bhabha

英雄这个词是为巴巴这样的人准备的

reaalreel

I am from the gorakhpur, harayana, PM in 2014 came here to enogurate the first nuclear power plant of north Indian,its not even 30 percent complete,but they promised it to be 2025. No govt body is looking at work ,all the private contractor are assigned work which is very very slow and you all know why

我来自哈拉亚纳邦的戈拉克布尔。2014年，总理承诺到这里修建印度北方的第一座核电站，现在还没有完工30%，但他们承诺2025年完工。

政府机构不作为，承包给了私人，进度非常缓慢，你们都知道为什么

devamjani8041

We are building new reactors rapidly right now. Don't worry, we will be a nuclear superpower within this decade.

我们现在正在迅速建造新的反应堆。别担心，我们将在十年内成为一个核超级大国。

Satyaki266

U know what, We Need A Dic ship. A Dictat who is Completely Focused in the Growth of our Country.

知道吗，我们需要一个专制的政府，全力发展国家的那种

lavanyasenthil3267

Why has India fallen behind today? What are the challenges that are paralyzing our growth in nuclear energy today?

India has faced challenges in the nuclear energy sector, including regulatory hurdles, safety concerns, public opposition, and international sanctions. These factors have hindered the growth of India's nuclear energy program and limited its expansion.

Where does India’s nuclear energy program stand today?

India's nuclear energy program has made significant progress since its inception. The country operates a number of nuclear power plants and continues to invest in nuclear research and development. However, challenges persist, and India faces the task of balancing nuclear energy growth with safety and security concerns.

为什么印度今天落后了？阻碍我们核能发展的挑战是什么？

印度在核能领域面临诸多挑战，包括监管障碍、安全担忧、民众反对和国际制裁。这些因素阻碍了印度核能项目的发展，限制了其扩张。

印度的核能项目目前处于什么位置？

印度的核能项目自启动以来取得了重大进展，运营着许多核电站，并继续投资于核研究与开发。然而，挑战依然存在，印度面临着平衡核能发展与安全问题的挑战。

S.T.E_YT

France has dried up its precious water bodies to run its nuclear power plants. The nuclear power plant can't be comletely shut down, you need a lot of water for cooling the reactor even in passive state to prevent reactor meltdown.

法国运行核电站，耗尽了宝贵的水源。核电站不能完全关闭，需要大量的水来冷却反应堆，即使在被动状态，以防止反应堆熔毁。

Dave-zyan

We need more inventions like west rather than normal food and textile tycoons  who just focus on filling their pocket . Working in West on super classified technologies , I believe we are really behind in the game . The west always does things secretively to make their position at least 2 or more decades ahead .

我们需要更多像西方那样的发明，而不是那些只关注自己口袋的食品和纺织大亨。我在西方从事超级机密技术的工作，我们真的落后了。西方总是秘密行事，领先至少20年或更长时间。

thehellsangel1

India needs to work faster towards this dream.. ASAP

印度需要加快实现这一梦想，尽快。

rohithbandari

Why should we be dependent on solar today too.

What are people in this country doing?????

为什么我们今天还要依赖太阳能呢？

这个国家的人在做什么？

alwaysSleepyBear26

Nuclear energy is losing its sex appeal even in western countries due to safety concerns. Many countries have announced programmes for reducing their shares of nuclear energy. This is one of the biggest reasons why there is a slowdown in scientific research.

由于安全问题，核能在西方国家也失去了吸引力。许多国家已经宣布了减少核能份额的计划。这是科学研究放缓的最大原因之一。

bhushanpatil7018

For India its will be A friend, A Neutral and A Strong Leader in world.

印度将成为世界的朋友、中立和强大的领导者。

Tanmay_IN

Oh man, you have to be kidding me if we still haven’t got the reactor!

This is unbelievable—knowing that this technology could make us an energy-surplus nation. Why on earth are our leaders and bureaucrats afraid to approve and fast-track the process? This isn’t the only case; it’s the same across every essential field, whether it’s the jet engine, AMCA, nuclear attack submarines, EVs, or many other things. It’s incredibly frustrating.

天啊，如果我们还没有反应堆，你一定是在开玩笑！

这是难以置信的——这项技术可以使我们成为一个能源过剩的国家。为什么我们的领导人和官僚们害怕批准这一进程？

这并不是个案，每个重要领域都是一样的，无论是喷气发动机、AMCA、核攻击潜艇、电动汽车还是其他许多东西，非常令人沮丧。

mugambo5505

corrupt politicians are eating everything

腐败的政客正在吞噬一切

7-man

Homi Bhabha and J.R.D Tata.. True patriots.

霍米·巴巴和塔塔是真正的爱国者。

spacetime3

America didnt end WW2 with the Bomb... you do good work but its important history correctly mentioned. The war was over by that point it was Japan who was seen as a country would not give up because of the culture of the time, the US needed a statement.

二战不是美国原子弹结束的，那时战争已经结束了，但日本不会放弃抵抗。

relaxngvideos2974

 that's incorrect . US after Japan nuke never wanted to repeat unless if attacked by another nation. It's over exaggeration we Indians want to keep repeating USSR helped india to thrawt USA  , same USSR supported china in 1965 war against India.  Let's not forget nations act based on their interests not for showing bollywood friendship like relationship towards us.

日本核爆后，美国从未想过再动用核武器，除非遭到另一个国家的攻击。我们印度人一直重申，说苏联帮助印度挫败了美国，同样，苏联在1965年中印冲突中支持中国。别忘了，各国的行动是基于自己的利益，而不是为了友谊。

truth_questioning

Briten fighted world War 1 and 2 by using the money of India

英国打第一次和第二次世界大战，花的是印度的钱

PrajwalDSouza

Indian government has paralyzed Scientists over the course of time. It is a torture for scientists to stay in India.

There was a time when scientists led missions, but it is now taken over by bureaucrats and politicians.

This is not a problem for India, it is a global problem that plagues NASA too. But it is getting worse in India.

There must be more power given to scientists to lead good programs without bureaucrats and politicans weighing them down.

随着时间的推移，印度政府让科学家们无用武之地。对科学家来说，留在印度是一种折磨。

曾经有一段时间由科学家领导任务，但现在被官僚和政客接管了。

这不是印度的问题，这也是困扰NASA的全球性问题。但印度的情况正在恶化。

必须给予科学家更多的权力，让他们在没有官僚和政客打压的情况下做好项目。

@S.T.E_YT

21:31 @ThinkSchool The cost of nuclear energy is very high due to safety precautions need to be taken in a nuclear plant are complex. Secondly the cost of renewables like solar energy and wind energy is decreasing year by year, therefore India is investing on affordable renewable energy than expensive nuclear energy.

核能的成本非常高，因为核电站需要采取的安全预防措施非常复杂。其次，太阳能和风能等可再生能源的成本逐年下降，印度正在投资实惠的可再生能源，而不是昂贵的核能。

arcothmmjaswanth4319

The day we prioritie the lives of our scientist's and great minds of our nation by providing the right security we'll advance more in any field.

等我们提供适当的安全保障，优先保护我们科学家的那一天，我们就能在各领域取得更大的进步。

pardhivvarma

Whenever you talk about India's development in the field of Education, Defence, Economic or any field the foundations go back to the contribution of the TATA's. Incredible family

Missing Ratan Tata Sir

每当你谈论印度在教育、国防、经济或任何领域的发展时，基础都要追溯到塔塔集团的贡献。令人难以置信的家族！怀念拉丹·塔塔

HereItsNow

Bruh atleast Leave India Out Of Wars Bruh . Isnt America alone enough to en 'd up whole humanity ?

至少不要让印度卷入战争。难道美国还不足以消灭全人类吗？

sunnyy6295

Thorium tech is must for India till date.

钍技术至今仍是印度的必需品。

murugandevara1982

Brother,

Could you please cover the US 36 Trillion debt.

Possibilities of US Default.

Impact in the world and mainly in India.

你能讲讲美国的36万亿债务吗？美国违约的可能性。对世界的影响，主要对印度的影响。