为什么印度不是核超级大国，印网友：一些西方大国秘密瘫痪了我们的国家几十年

Why is India not a Nuclear Superpower ?

为什么印度不是核超级大国？

以下是外国网友的评论：

surajkumar5182

Not just Homi Bhabha but more than 11 Indian nuclear scientists have died Mysterious death we all are too busy in our internal conflicts so much that some western powers are secretly paralyzing our country for decades

不仅仅是霍米·巴巴，还有超过11名印度核科学家离奇死亡。我们忙于内部冲突了，一些西方大国秘密瘫痪了我们的国家几十年

Ronit_9977

Don't know how much blood shed is there in our history. Many sacrificed themselves for us, but are unknown. I hope, we will make the dreams of Sir Bhabha true soon and make India a roaring golden lion. Jai Bharat

不知道我们的历史上发生了多少流血事件。很多人为我们牺牲了自己，却不为人知。我希望，我们能尽快实现巴巴先生的梦想，让印度成为咆哮的金狮。印度必胜！

Sarcasmmemes

Man, we'll have to accept that our forefathers were purely genius and quite visionary.

Hats off to them.

我们得承认我们的祖先是天才，而且很有远见。向他们致敬。

JSnwl-ng5zq

Everyone today is like "Soviet helped India in 1971, we are true brother's" but we must realise that it was in Soveit union where shastri ji died. If he had not died we could have achieved Nuclear bomb before 1971 war. If we had nuke then no country would have dared to attack India and we wouldn't have needed USSR for help in the first place.

每个人都在说“苏联在1971年帮助了印度，我们是真正的兄弟”，但我们必须意识到，沙斯特里吉是在苏联去世的。如果他没有死，我们可以在1971年战争前制造出核弹。如果我们有核武器，那就没有国家敢攻击印度，我们一开始就不需要苏联的帮助了。

srisudharsrinivasan8336

When India does try to go forward, people of India will protest severly against it like they protested against the kudankulam reactor.

And when we try other options like biogas, farmers will protest against it (happening now in Punjab)

当印度试图向前发展时，印度人民会像抗议库丹库拉姆反应堆一样强烈抗议。

当我们尝试沼气等其他选择时，农民会抗议（旁遮普邦正在发生这种情况）。

SanjayPatendla10

"In Geopolitics there are no friends, only benefits and rivals."

It's true ,we should be conscious while making friendship with countries. And we have our man ,Mr.Jai Shankar putting it in the right way

“在地缘政治中，没有朋友，只有利益和对手。”

这是真的，我们在与其他国家建立友谊时，应该意识到这一点。

Satyaki266

U know what, We Need A Dic ship. A Dr who is Completely Focused in the Growth of our Country.

我们需要一个独才政权，一个完全专注于国家发展的独才者。

Laxmanca

if indian government starts giving more attention and focus on our scientists,trust me our nation can really boost in technology

如果印度政府开始更多地关注我们的科学家，我们国家真的可以在技术上取得进步

pardhivvarma

Whenever you talk about India's development in the field of Education, Defence, Economic or any field the foundations go back to the contribution of the TATA's. Incredible family

Missing Ratan Tata Sir

每当谈论印度在教育、国防、经济或任何领域的发展时，都要追溯到塔塔集团的贡献。令人难以置信的家族，想念拉丹·塔塔先生！

mugambo5505

It's sad to see how these geniuses changed India's fate but corrupt politicians are eating everything

这些天才努力改变印度的命运，但腐败的政客正在吞噬一切

Dave-zyan

We need more inventions like west rather than normal food and textile tycoons who just focus on filling their pocket . Working in West on super classified technologies , I believe we are really behind in the game . The west always does things secretively to make their position at least 2 or more decades ahead .

我们需要更多像西方那样的发明，而不是那些只关注自己口袋的食品和纺织大亨。我在西方从事超级机密技术的工作，我认为相信我们真的落后了。西方总是秘密行事，以使自己领先至少20年。

relaxngvideos2974

18:25 that's incorrect . US after Japan nuke never wanted to repeat unless if attacked by another nation. It's over exaggeration we Indians want to keep repeating USSR helped india to thrawt USA , same USSR supported china in 1965 war against India. Let's not forget nations act based on their interests not for showing bollywood friendship like relationship towards us.

日本核爆后，美国从未想过再来一次，除非遭到另一个国家的攻击。我们印度人想要不断重复苏联帮助印度击败美国，但是苏联在1965年印中战争中支持中国。别忘了，各国的行动是基于他们的利益，而不是为了展示宝莱坞式的友谊。

thehellsangel1

India needs to work faster towards this dream.. ASAP

印度需要加快实现这一梦想，尽快

rameshvenkateshappa8443

You missed a issue that's related to this topic. Our neuclear scientists dead mysteriously from 2004 to 2016 they're working in kaiga neuclear power plant Karnataka...

从2004年到2016年，我们在卡纳塔克邦的kaiga核电站工作的核科学家神秘死亡。

Aruntej.L

KAMINI (Kalpakkam Mini reactor) - the world's only thorium-based experimental reactor. It produces 40 MW of thermal energy at full power.

卡米尼（Kalpakkam迷你反应堆）-世界上唯一的钍基实验反应堆。它在全功率时能产生40兆瓦的热能。

abiuniverse

As an insider into India's nuclear scientist community, I can tell you that we need more collaboration for India's nuclear dream to work. No one is working towards new nuclear technology except very few; the rest are wasting their time on stupid research to get grant money. The amount of exploitation in Indian academia (especially physics, from my perspective) is unreal, and that is the biggest enemy of our nation.

作为印度核科学家社区的内部人士，我可以告诉你们，我们需要更多的合作来实现印度的核梦想。除了极少数人之外，没有人致力于开发新的核技术；其余的人都在浪费时间做愚蠢的研究，目的是为了获得资助。印度学术界（尤其是物理学）的研发是不真实的，这是我们国家最大的敌人。

rohithbandari

Why aren't people like homi bhabha or apj Abdul Kalam exst today in India in 21st century who are actually close with top Indian govt officials like homi was.

India eagerly need these kind of people. Why should we be dependent on solar today too. What are people in this country doing?

为什么21世纪的印度没有像homi bhabha或apj Abdul Kalam这样的人才。

印度迫切需要这样的人。为什么我们今天还要依赖太阳能呢？这个国家的人在做什么？

vipulgupta

Choose your words carefully. US didn't put an end to WW2 by drop those bombs. First of all WW2 was ended by Soviets once they captured Berlin and second US dropped those bombs despite knowing WW2 has ended and Japan has agreed to surrender. There was absolutely zero need for those bombs to be dropped. Speak the history as it was, not the Western version.

用词要谨慎，美国不是靠投炸弹结束二战的。首先，二战是苏联占领柏林后结束的，其次，尽管美国知道二战已经结束，日本已经同意投降，但美国还是投下了那些炸弹，完全没有必要投的。要讲真实的历史，而不是西方的版本。

truth_questioning

Briten fighted world War 1 and 2 by using the money of India

英国在第一次和第二次世界大战中使用的是印度的钱

S.T.E_YT

France has dried up its precious water bodies to run its nuclear power plants. The nuclear power plant can't be comletely shut down, you need a lot of water for cooling the reactor even in passive state to prevent reactor meltdown.

为了运行核电站，法国已经耗尽了宝贵的水体。核电站不能完全关闭，你需要大量的水来冷却反应堆，即使在被动状态，以防止反应堆熔毁。

arcothmmjaswanth4319

The day we prioritie the lives of our scientist's and great minds of our nation by providing the right security we'll advance more in any field.

到我们能为科学家提供充分保障的那一天，我们将在任何领域取得更大的进步。

devamjani8041

We are building new reactors rapidly right now. Don't worry, we will be a nuclear superpower within this decade.

我们现在正在迅速建造新的反应堆。别担心，我们将在这十年内成为一个核超级大国。

sweetyforever1876

A CIA agent wrote in his book that they were responsible for shastri death and homi bhabha plane accident

一名中情局特工在他的书中写道，他们对shastri的死亡和homi bhabha飞机事故负有责任

S.T.E_YT

The cost of nuclear energy is very high due to safety precautions need to be taken in a nuclear plant are complex. Secondly the cost of renewables like solar energy and wind energy is decreasing year by year, therefore India is investing on affordable renewable energy than expensive nuclear energy.

核能的成本非常高，因为核电站需要采取的安全预防措施非常复杂。其次，太阳能和风能等可再生能源的成本逐年下降，因此印度正在投资可负担得起的可再生能源，而不是昂贵的核能。

_.falcon777._

The biggest problem is Indian Education system . No one focuses on research and if someone wants too , they can't because there are very less facilities or salary and more exploitation.

Everyone is just running to get a government job No one cars about the Country or any other person . People literally don't have basic civic sense here .

If we want to go grow as a country our main focus should be Research & Development.

There are so many flaws in our country's system.

I'm deeply saddened to see the state of Our country.

I hope more educated youth and people run the country

最大的问题是印度的教育体系。没有人把重点放在研究上，即使有人想这样做，他们也做不到，因为设备和工资都很少，而且压榨严重。

每个人都只是为了得到一份政府工作，没有人关心国家或其他任何人。这里的人根本没有基本的公民意识。如果我们国家想要发展，我们的主要重点应该是研发。

我们国家的制度有很多缺陷。看到我们国家的现状，我深感悲痛。我希望受过教育的年轻人来管理这个国家

flash6797

Gist: we don’t have uranium, we have to import it. So we have been experimenting with thorium for 40 years and are in stage 2

重点：我们没有铀，必须进口。因此，我们对钍的实验已经进行了40年，目前正处于第二阶段

Tanmay_IN

21:40, Oh man, you have to be kidding me if we still haven’t got the reactor!

This is unbelievable—knowing that this technology could make us an energy-surplus nation. Why on earth are our leaders and bureaucrats afraid to approve and fast-track the process? This isn’t the only case; it’s the same across every essential field, whether it’s the jet engine, AMCA, nuclear attack submarines, EVs, or many other things. It’s incredibly frustrating.

我们还没有反应堆，你一定是在开玩笑！这是难以置信的——掌握这项技术可以使我们成为一个能源过剩的国家。为什么我们的领导人和官僚们害怕批准和加快这一进程？这并不是唯一的情况，每个重要领域都是这样，无论是喷气发动机、AMCA、核攻击潜艇、电动汽车还是其他。这非常令人沮丧。

malaykisku091

India has 172 nuclear warheads in 2024!

2024年印度有172枚核弹头！

xscorp382

Day by day, My hate for US becomes bigger.

我对美国的仇恨与日俱增。

PrajwalDSouza

It is a torture for scientists to stay in India.

There was a time when scientists led missions, but it is now taken over by bureaucrats and politicians.

This is not a problem for India, it is a global problem that plagues NASA too. But it is getting worse in India.

There must be more power given to scientists to lead good programs without bureaucrats and politicans weighing them down.

对科学家来说，留在印度是一种折磨。

曾经有一段时间由科学家领导任务，但现在被官僚和政治家接管了。

这不仅是印度的问题，也是全球性问题，困扰NASA。但印度的情况正在恶化。

必须给予科学家更多的权力，让他们在没有官僚和政客打压的情况下领导好的项目。

alwaysSleepyBear26

Nuclear energy is losing its sex appeal even in western countries due to safety concerns. Many countries have announced programmes for reducing their shares of nuclear energy. This is one of the biggest reasons why there is a slowdown in scientific research. You should have covered this in video.

由于安全问题，核能在西方国家也失去了吸引力。许多国家已经宣布了减少核能份额的计划。这是科学研究放缓的最大原因之一。

llawliet365

I disagree that we need to increase our dependency on Nuclear.

Nuclear is not cost efficient and could also be dangerous in case of even a minor accident. Nuclear Waste is also a big issue.

India is gifted with ample amount of sunlight through out the year unlike Europe or US.

We should make use of it instead.

Solar Energy is very cost efficient and getting more and more affordable.

我认为我们不需要增加对核能的依赖。

核能的成本效益不高，甚至在发生小事故时也可能很危险。核废料也是一个大问题。与欧洲和美国不同，印度全年都有充足的阳光，我们应该加以利用。

太阳能的成本效益很高，而且越来越便宜。

sunnyy6295

Thorium tech is must for India till date.