印度能为“光辉”战机敲定发动机吗

Can India clinch desi engine deal for Tejas fighter aircraft? Buzz as Jaishankar visits France

印度能敲定“光辉”战机的引擎设计协议吗？外交部长苏杰生访问法国

External Affairs Minister Jaishankar is in France on a 3-day visit; aimed at cementing bilateral defence cooperation. Strong buzz - Jaishankar may discuss sharing tech to produce 100 kilo newton thrust Safran engines in India. Last year, Defence Minister Rajnath Singh stated France has agreed to jointly build aircraft engine. Modi Govt has already stated in Parliament that it has proposed to develop engines with an int'l engine house.

印度外长杰苏杰生正在法国进行为期3天的访问，旨在加强双边防务合作。苏杰生可能会讨论技术分享事宜，在印度生产10万牛顿推力的赛峰发动机。去年，印度国防部长拉杰纳特·辛格表示，法国已经同意联合制造飞机发动机。莫迪政府已经在议会上表示，已经提议和外国公司联合开发发动机。

以下是印度网民的评论：

G Sander

This will be a historic milestone

这将是一个历史性的里程碑

Artichokie

With an operating radius if 300KM the Tejas can only be used in Defense ops. It can't be used in an Attacking role. Anyways, it appears that India needs to lay an additional order of more Rafale's if it want's to push forward with the Engine development. Dassault and Safran aren't stupid, they want to sell fighter jets and wouldn't want to help a key business prospect to start manufacturing his own jets. So I believe France may push India to buy additional jets to incentivize and push Safran for this defense cooperation.

如果飞行半径为300公里，光辉战机只能用于防御，不能用于攻击。

不管怎样，如果印度想要推进发动机的研发，似乎需要下更多的阵风战机订单。

达索和赛峰并不愚蠢，他们想卖战斗机，不会平白无故教你造飞机。

因此，我认为法国可能会要求印度购买更多的战机，以激励和推动赛峰集团进行防务合作。

Akhilesh Mohan

MEA minister is working so hard for the nation. Kudos to PM Modi’s team for the work effort. Since 2014 we have a visible govt that’s taking us forward. Lot of work to be done still but I’m sure these folks know what they are doing.

印度外交部长为国家兢兢业业，向莫迪总理团队致敬。自2014年以来，我们迎来了一个高瞻远瞩的政府，带领我们前进。

还有很多工作要做，我相信这些人知道他们在做什么。

Nageswarao Patha

No one beat This government in foreign affairs

在外交事务上，以前没有一届印度政府能比得上本届政府

Advait K

Would make absolutely no sense, we have GE's

这完全没有意义，我们有通用公司的引擎

Sirius

Only a handful of countries like the U.S, Russia, France and the U.K manufacture jet engines and their related technologies are closely guarded secret among them. None of those countries will transfer the technologies to India. Safran may only commit to a limited help in engine related tech though.

制造喷气发动机的国家只有美国、俄罗斯、法国、英国等少数几个国家，其相关技术一直处于保密状态。这些国家都不会把技术转让给印度。赛峰集团可能只会在发动机相关技术方面提供有限的帮助。

FrontMan-132

Tejas Mk-2, AMCA, TEDBF, ORKA, a lot to come

光辉Mk-2, AMCA, TEDBF, ORKA，还有很多本土战机要上线了

Bobbili Santoosh

We should go for Roll Royce for engines because they are giving full IP rights to India with TOT, not like France will not give IP rights to India. Safran engine trust can't be increased so future technologies like laser weapons can't be used or new technologies can't be integrated but RR engine trust can be increased up to 120kn

我们应该用劳斯莱斯的引擎，他们给了印度全部的知识产权，而法国不给印度知识产权。

赛峰发动机的推力无法提高，因此未来的技术，如激光武器，不能使用或新技术不能集成，

但劳斯莱斯发动机的推力可以提高到120kn

Acharya

Indigenisation of defence is something Congress never thought about huh?

武器本土化是国大党从未考虑过的事情，对吧?

Surojeet Chatterjee

Alternatives r always important, u never know when USA gonna stop supplying engines.

替代选择总是很重要，你永远不知道美国什么时候会停止提供引擎。

Sahil Thakur

There was a time we rely on russia for satellite launch.... Now we have pslv, gslv, and many more...... Just wait ,its only 75 yrs since independence.. India will soon have more affordable and efficient engines....

曾经有一段时间我们依靠俄罗斯发射卫星....现在我们有pslv、gslv等运载火箭......等着瞧吧，印度独立才75年。印度很快就会出现更多廉价高效的发动机....

Manas

Own engine makes more self sufficient .

本土发动机，自给自足。

RedFireTree

making jet engine is not like dreaming you can do it day or at night, jet engine needs high temperature tolerating materials, first with alloy metal then mono crystal alloy then ceramic alloy then..go on also with ceramic coating.....

制造喷气发动机不像做梦那么简单，白天或晚上都可以做梦，制造喷气发动机需要耐高温材料，首先是合金金属，然后是单晶合金、陶瓷合金、陶瓷涂层等等

betaharish

I love Tejas.

我爱“光辉”战机。

Read

Throw them away. They are the most useless fighter jets ever made.

放弃光辉战机吧，它们是有史以来最没用的战斗机。

gireesh kumar

Its operational range is 800km

Take off distance 480m

Landing distance 700m

Donnot speed misinformation

“光辉”战机的作战范围是800公里，起飞距离480米，着陆距离700米

不要传播错误信息

RedFireTree

people of this country just do not realize how far they are behind, still dreaming 5th, 6th 7th ...gen fighters, hah

这个国家的人没有意识到他们落后了多远，仍然梦想着第5代、第6代战机，哈哈

m.kumar Pillai

Indian engineers should Develop engine indigenously

印度工程师应该自主研发引擎

RK G

India should make its own weapons and engines

印度应该自己造武器和引擎

Vertigo Hotel

Tejas will kick the ass of Yankee supremacy's air

光辉战机将会让美国佬的空中霸主地位黯然失色

MS2021

When will India make hi tech equipments on its own . Where are our engineers . If Elon Musk alone can build rocket engine successfully , our DRDO ISRO like large organisations what are they for?

印度什么时候能自己制造高科技武器。我们的工程师在哪里？

如果埃隆·马斯克个人都能成功造出火箭引擎，

我们的印度国防研究与发展组织(DRDO)和印度空间研究组织(ISRO)这样的大型组织怎么没这个能力。

他们是干嘛的?

Foreign Policy Hawk

Desi engines….

设计引擎？

no name

Don't believe any country when it comes jet engine tech

在喷气发动机技术方面，不要相信任何国家

d.ź

Good news

好消息

Steven X

waste of money, waste of energy on such a useless thing

在这种无用的事情上浪费金钱、浪费精力

Sow Chowdhury

100 Rafale jet fighters Deal with France. Need Indian navy.

向法国购买100架“阵风”战机，印度海军也需要

Raghavendra Kumar Kandaswami Pillai

Jai Hind

印度必胜！

RedFireTree

you have dream, you have plan, you want to make it, but you just cannot. Making jet engine cost huge amount of money, which you do not have, you are just a 3rd world develo country, you do not have basic research for it, your total R&S budget is only 0.6-0.7% of your GDP

你们有梦想，你们有计划，你们想去实现它，但你们就是做不到。制造喷气发动机要花很多钱，而你们没有，

你们只是第三世界的发展中国家，你们基础研究不够，你们的研发预算只有GDP的0.6-0.7%

random

But that wont be indigenous .

那不是本土引擎。

love Level

No order from word despite 10 air shows

尽管参加了10场航空展，但“光辉”战机没有收到任何国外订单啊