俄罗斯会不会在不久的将来沦为中国的卫星国

Will Russia become a satellite state of China in the near future?

俄罗斯会不会在不久的将来沦为中国的卫星国？

nimg.ws.126.jpg

以下是QUORA网友的评论：

Paul Denlinger

Lived in China, Taiwan and Hong Kong; fluent in PutonghuaAuthor has 11.5K answers and 54.5M answer viewsOct 1

When you consider that China is the single largest trading partner of 120+ countries, you might argue that Russia will not be alone in orbiting China.

Some of its company includes the US and EU, which are becoming more dependent on Chinese imports

你要知道一个事实，中国是120多个国家的最大贸易伙伴。也许你会说，俄罗斯并唯一一个围着中国团团转的国家。

俄罗斯并不孤单，美国和欧盟也越来越依赖中国的进口

Johannes

Former GeographerAuthor has 198 answers and 45.6K answer viewsOct 1

It wil depend mostly on the developments over the next months, I wouldn't be surprised if the Russian Federation will fall apart over the upcoming years. Some of the eastern states will be highly influenced by China, those in the west may move very slow into the European sphere of influence. And Russia of course will try to get some of the cake, too.

Anyway, the future looks a lot brighter for China than for Russia.

我认为这取决于未来几个月的事态发展如何，就算俄罗斯联邦这几年就解体也不足为奇。俄罗斯的东部地区已经受中国影响很深，西部地区可能会慢慢并入欧洲的势力范围。俄罗斯当然也想分一杯羹。

但不管怎么说，中国的前景会比俄罗斯明朗得多。

Tony Tan

Former Self Employed TraderAuthor has 14.3K answers and 11.1M answer viewsOct 1

Certainly not. We all have to support Russia because it is doing the world a big favour. It keeps 6000 nuclear missiles pointing towards the US.

当然不会了。我们都必须支持俄罗斯，因为它能帮世界解决一个大麻烦：它的6000枚核导弹瞄准了美国。

David Chan

Former Senior Exec now retired (1985–2010)Author has 21.5K answers and 2.7M answer viewsOct 1

Thanks for requesting my answer.

No, that is highly unlikely. It may be possible to that the Asian parts may splinter off and fall under the influence of China but the Western parts are unlikely to do that.

谢谢邀请我来回答问题。

不会，可能性极低。俄罗斯的亚洲部分可能会独立出来，落入中国的影响之下，但西部地区不太可能。

Ti-Min Monfet

Author has 346 answers and 28.8K answer viewsOct 2

No. China has Powers that Russia doesn’t, but also vice-versa.

In the Present Global Context, a fair partnership is a GOOD DEAL for both countries.

不会。中国有的，俄罗斯没有，反之亦然，俄罗斯有的，中国也没有。

在当前的全球局势下，公平的伙伴关系对两国都是一笔好交易。

Mitch Mitchel

Studied at Traveler of the WorldAuthor has 3.4K answers and 304K answer viewsOct 2

Not in the near future. It’s impossible to predict the outcome of this war given Russia putting the west on notice with the gas pipeline sabotage. There are communications cables also costing billions, Pupu escalates almost daily now. , measures and counter measures. Russia if the whole world does not blow up is toast. It’s not a good signal from Pupu, this may be the final phase of his tenure and he appears to be burning his bridges.

Putin thinks by escalating he can break the alliance.

近期不可能。我们无法预判这场战争的结果，因为俄罗斯破坏了天然气管道，引发了西方的关注。还有价值数十亿美元的通信电缆，措施和应对措施几乎每天都在升级。普京的任期可能快结束了，似乎在自断后路。

普京认为事态升级可以破坏联盟。

Guido Sgarbi

Studied at Università Cattolica Del Sacro Cuore (Graduated 2004)Author has 597 answers and 365.5K answer viewsMar 1

Will Russia now become a servant state of China?

No. China is, albeit unformally, just an ally of Russia.

Western Countries, instead…especially NATO members …are slaves to the USA!

不会。中国只是俄罗斯的盟友。

相反，西方国家，特别是北约成员国，都是美国的走狗！

Frank Fernando

Businessman (2005–present)Oct 1

Who is china by the way compare to Russia?. Even the smallest country in the could not a stellite country of china.

Russian people are rich has better life than chinese.

跟俄罗斯相比，中国算老几啊？没有哪个国家会成为中国的卫星国。

俄罗斯人很富有，生活水平比中国人高。

Jaap Folmer

European federalistAuthor has 6.5K answers and 6.6M answer viewsMar 10

Will isolated Russia become an economical satellite of China?

Mr. Putin is about to face some hard realities and one is that he cannot borrow power from China. Now that he has burned his bridges to the West, even to Germany that had been trying to be a good partner for so long, he will find out that Chinese help will come at a price. Whether Russia will indeed become an economical satellite, depends on how long the current policies will be continued. At this moment that is hard to predict because the war in Ukraine still hangs in the balance and the economic consequences still have to hit Russia. This is expected to happen in the next few weeks. Then Mr. Putin will have some tough decisions to make.

摆在普京面前的是一些严峻的现实，其中之一就是他不能向中国借力。现在他已经斩断了与西方的桥梁，甚至断绝了长期以来跟德国一直努力保持的良好伙伴关系。他会明白中国的援助是有代价的。俄罗斯会不会真的变成一个经济卫星国，取决于目前的政策要持续多久。目前还很难说，因为乌克兰战争还没结束，俄罗斯肯定会受到经济冲击。估计几个礼拜就会见分晓了。到那个时候，普京就必须做出一些艰难的决定了。

He can try to sell his gas to the Chinese, but since the required pipelines are not there yet, this will take time. The Chinese probably want it for cheap, because they know he needs to sell.

他可以向中国出售天然气，但输送管道尚未建成，还需要些时间。中国人可能会压价，因为他们知道俄罗斯需要这笔交易。

Jeffy

Author has 2.4K answers and 526.4K answer viewsMar 12

Why would Vladimir Putin allow his beloved Russia to potentially become a satellite state of China?

DOESN’T WORK THAT WAY.

THE RUSSIA CHINA BROTHERHOOD IS TOO STRONG FOR THAT TYPE OF BS

SATELLITE STATE IS A TACTIC THE USA USES ON THE EU. JUST ASK THE GERMANS.

不会的。

俄罗斯和中国有深厚的兄弟情谊。

卫星国是美国用来对付欧盟的手段。不信的话去问问德国人。

Teang Shui Lee

Former ProfessorMar 13

Will Russia depend on China in the future?

My bet is these 2 countries will look after each other in future given the antagonistic world.

要我说，因为其他国家的敌对态度，这两个国家反而会互相关照，惺惺相惜。

R. W. Carmichael

Former Intelligence Analyst at U.S. Air Force (1962–1970)Author has 6.3K answers and 8.9M answer viewsMay 2

What is the probability that Russia one day will become a satellite nation of China?

Actually it is getting higher moment by moment. The problem is that Russia’s economy is incredibly two-dimensional, dependent almost entirely on oil and gas exports with exports of military hardware coming in a very distant second.

Russia only had the #12 economy in the world, smaller than that of Italy or Brazil. It is slated to drop to #32 in GDP by the end of this year. And it really has no allies not ability to defeat sanctions.

这个可能性与日俱增。俄罗斯的问题在于，经济几乎完全依赖石油和天然气的出口，远超排在第二位的军火出口。

俄罗斯的经济规模仅排在世界第12位，落后于意大利和巴西。预计到今年年底，它的GDP将降至第32位。俄罗斯没有盟友，没有能力对抗制裁。

As the Russian economy crumbles, it will eventually have to deal with China on China’s terms. And China shamelessly manipulates its two-currency system to its advantage at every opportunity. That means that everything Russia sells to China will happen at about a 30–50% discount and everything Russia buys from China will happen at a 30–50% markup.

Eventually, China will be Russia’s biggest trading partner in this unfair relationship. i will manipulate Russia to be another North Korea. But the difference is that China will extort huge amounts of military technology from Russia in the process. And i will stay on the fence on sanctions, enforcing them just enough to keep Russia bound into the status quo.

俄罗斯经济一旦崩溃，就必须依照中国的条件与中国打交道。中国利用每一个机会操纵其双重货币体系。这意味着俄罗斯出售给中国的商品都会有30-50%的折扣，而俄罗斯从中国采购的商品则会有30-50%的加价。

最终，在这种不公平的关系中，中国将成为俄罗斯最大的贸易伙伴。但中国会在这个过程中从俄罗斯敲诈到大量的军事技术。

The GDP of Russia before the Second Ukraine War was about $1.4 trillion USD. It is slated to drop to around $.8 trillion by the end of the year. The GDP of China is about $12 trillion use — currently over ten times as large. The GDP of the US is $18.5 trillion. The GDP of NATO countries combined is around $38 trillion USD.

第二次乌克兰战争前，俄罗斯的GDP约为1.4万亿美元，今年年底预计将降至0.8万亿美元左右。中国的GDP大约是12万亿美元，是俄罗斯的10倍。美国的GDP是18.5万亿美元。北约国家的GDP加起来约38万亿美元。

Salvatore Barrera

Author has 18.4K answers and 3.3M answer viewsFeb 9

What will be the future of Russia as a subject of China?

To answer this question, it would require another question in that do you know WHY China is dependent on Russia for the benefit of Sino-Russian relationships?

It’s because, a few years ago, Russia and China signed an agreement by i and Putin, in that Russia has contracted to provide China with 30 years of natural gas for at least $400 billion. That is why i and Putin became very geopolitically and geoeconomically close, too.

要回答这个问题，还需要先搞清楚另一个问题，你知道为什么中国为了中俄关系的好处而依赖俄罗斯吗？

这是因为，几年前俄罗斯和中国签署了一项协议，俄罗斯以至少4000亿美元的价格向中国提供30年的天然气。这就是两国在地缘政治和地缘经济上也变得非常亲密的原因。

So therefore, the future of China’s One Belt One Road Initiative will be the future of China’s access and availability of Russian natural gas and its expansion of the OBOR into Africa will also necessitate the construction of MORE coal-fired power plants on that continent, too. But, of course, the above plans could change like the weather, too.

The above will mean that China will be the LARGEST consumer of hydrocarbons on Earth, too.

So the future of China will also be the subject of Russia, too.

因此，中国“一带一路”的未来就是中国获取俄罗斯天然气的未来，而将一带一路建设到非洲也需要在非洲大陆建设更多的燃煤发电厂。当然，这也可能随着气候的变化而变化。

这意味着中国也将成为地球上最大的碳氢化合物消费国。

因此，中国的未来也将是俄罗斯的发展主题。

Ray Comeau

Decades working in analyzing risk and plotting strategyAuthor has 6.4K answers and 8.3M answer views4y

Is it possible for Pakistan to become a satellite state of China like the Soviet Bloc?

NO.

China has no interest in acquiring or overseeing territory that it not considers to be part of China.

China is a nation state with a Han culture. It is not interested in changing its long cultural tradition into becoming a multi-cultural one.

Like Japan and North and South Korea, the nation state is fundamental to who China is.

不可能。

中国无意强占或插手不属于中国的领土。

中国是一个汉族文化为主的国家。中国并不热衷于将本国悠久的传统文化变成多元文化。

跟日本、朝鲜和韩国一样，单一民族的中国才是中国。

Bruce Li

a Chinese with some overseas experiencesAuthor has 259 answers and 245K answer views6y

What do you think will China invade Russia in the future or not?

Why would China invade a country that is cold,empty,has nuclear weapons?

Seriously, I never heard anyone saying that China should invade Russia for its lands. It's dangerous. It's not worth it. China already has a lot of stuff to be busy with. South China Sea,easy China sea,Taiwan,Vietnam,Japan,north Korea,south korea,America...and so on.

Let Russia and China be good friends. It's good for both sides.

为什么中国要入侵一个气候严寒，人烟稀薄，拥有核武器的国家?

讲真，我从没听过有人说过中国应该入侵俄罗斯。这太危险了，根本不值得冒险。中国现在就有很多事务要处理，南中国海、台湾地区、越南、日本、朝鲜、韩国、美国…

俄罗斯和中国应该成为好朋友，这对彼此都有好处。

Ethan James Coronel

Studied at Ateneo de Manila University (Graduated 2021)Author has 1.5K answers and 5.4M answer views2y

If China is able to subdue the world militarily in the future, would Russia become subservient to it?

Original question: “If China is able to subdue the world militarily in the future, would Russia become subservient to it?”

No.

Russia is also a military superpower. She boasts around the same amount of nuclear warheads America has—around 7000+. China is said to only have 200+.

Unless Beiing ramps up production of nuclear weapons to level the playing field, I don’t see Moscow ever bowing down to her.

Besides, China, at least for now, believes in a multipolar world—a sentiment that I share. That’s why I want a strong but benevolent America, Russia and India to serve as a safeguard against a potentially belligerent nuclear-armed China in the future.

不会。

俄罗斯也是一个超级军事大国，吹嘘自己拥有的核弹头可以和美国媲美——大约7000多枚，据说中国只有200多枚。

除非中国加紧制造核武器，追赶美俄，否则我认为莫斯科不会向中国低头。

此外，至少在目前这个阶段，中国希望世界是多极的——我也有同感。所以我希望强大但仁爱的美国、俄罗斯和印度能共同抵御中国这个拥有核武器的潜在敌对国。