Indians are also being laid off in the US and honestly, the real problem is …:

在美国的印度人也被裁员了，真正的问题是…

A debate regarding Indian immigrants and H-1B visas is raging in the US. Tesla CEO Elon Musk who played a key role in the election campaign of the US President-elect Donald Trump is a strong supporter of H-1B visas. Musk, who along with Indian-American tech entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy has been tapped by Trump to lead his Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), argued last week that foreign workers are needed for tech companies like Musk's SpaceX and Tesla.

在美国，一场关于印度移民和H-1B签证的辩论正在激烈进行。特斯拉CEO埃隆·马斯克在美国当选总统唐纳德·特朗普的竞选活动中发挥了关键作用，他是H-1B签证的坚定支持者。马斯克与印度裔美国科技企业家维韦克·拉马斯瓦米一起被特朗普任命领导政府效率部（DOGE）。马斯克上周表示，马斯克的SpaceX和特斯拉等科技公司需要外国工人。

Perplexty AI founder Aravind Srinivas argues against the focus on H-1B visas. He told the Economic Times that the focus on H-1B visas is misplaced and unsupported by data, emphasizing illegal immigration as the more pressing issue.” Srinivas has previously worked at DeepMind, Google, and OpenAI. His company, Perplexty AI, is reportedly valued at $9 billion.

Perplexty AI创始人阿拉文德·斯里尼瓦斯反对将重点放在H-1B签证上。他接受《印度经济时报》采访时表示，把重点放在H-1B签证上是错误的，没有数据支持，他强调非法移民是更紧迫的问题。斯里尼瓦斯此前曾在DeepMind、谷歌和OpenAI工作。据报道，他的公司Perplexty AI估值为90亿美元。

"Clearly, it surprised everybody online and it's not exactly data driven -- the claims that the H-1B or Indian immigrants are taking away the jobs of laid-off American tech workers,” Srinivas stated in an interview. He pointed out that Indians are also affected by layoffs and that the government should prioritize addressing illegal immigration. "Indians are also being laid off and honestly, the real problem… is the illegal immigration. That’s what the government needs to cut down on. The numbers are just an order of magnitude higher there, and even in legal immigration, the problem is actually that the sectors in which people are getting laid off are not necessarily the ones that the Indian H-1B applications are coming. People getting laid off are not necessarily all engineers. If people actually took a look at the data and saw it for themselves, they wouldn't be this angry," he added.

斯里尼瓦斯在接受采访时表示：“显然，这让网上的每个人都感到惊讶，声称H-1B签证或印度移民正在夺走被裁员的美国科技工作者的工作，并没有数据支持。”他指：“印度人也受到裁员的影响，政府应该优先解决非法移民问题。印度人也被解雇了，老实说，真正的问题是非法移民。这正是政府需要削减的。印度的数字要高出一个数量级，甚至在合法移民方面，问题实际上是，那些裁员的行业并不一定是印度H-1B申请的行业。被解雇的人不一定都是工程师。如果人们真的看看这些数据，亲眼看看，他们就不会这么生气了。”

H-1B visa debate that has divided

关于H-1B签证的争论存在分歧

This fierce H-1B visa debate is said to have divided Trump's supporters into two factions: One side supports H-1B visas, while the other opposes them. Figures like Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy have expressed support for H-1B visas, while others have criticized this stance.

这场激烈的H-1B签证辩论将特朗普的支持者分成了两派：一派支持H-1B签证，另一派则反对。埃隆·马斯克和维韦克·拉马斯瓦米等人物表示支持H-1B签证，而其他人则批评了这种立场。

印度时报读者的评论：

3 h

Modi and AI in same sentence can evoke only laughter. His definition of AI on YT is iconic comedy

把莫迪和AI放在一句话里都让人发笑。他对AI的定义就是一个笑话

3 1 • Reply • Flag

Atul bhaiyya : There are 3 types of people:,1. Educated ,,2. Un-educated ,,3. Educated Un-educated (,Modi maybe Category 2. But, you are Category 3, the most dangerous tribe.

世界上有三种人。1.受过教育的  2.没受过教育的 3.受过教育的文盲，莫迪可能是第二类。但是，你是第三类，是最危险的。

Strategic Speaking

All Bhakths want to goto US and start controlling India from there

所有印度教徒都想去美国，在那里控制印度

0 1 • Reply • Flag

Don't worry Alen Musk,There is no shortage of the experts produced by our enlightened technology institutes, who by hook or crook will arrange to come to your support, by leaving BLOODY INDIA

别担心，马斯克，我们不缺人才，他们会想方设法离开血腥的印度去支持你

Movie

Ind!an$ are a canc€₹ and should be th₹0wn out of usa or better s&

印度人是毒瘤，要赶出美国

Vaanar Sainik

karma bites back buddy. u planted enemies here. now suffer the consequences

你在这里树敌，不怕报应吗

Movie

Are you threatening me?

你在威胁我吗？

Kaiser

The USA is monotheistic faith country but the BlackUglyHinduStreetShittingRapists are a bunch of pagans. They must leave.

美国是一个一神信仰的国家，但街头的黑人是一群异教徒，他们必须离开。

4 1 • Reply • Flag

H1b folks in the US have contributed a lot, no doubt in it. But there is a lot of misuse and exploitation also by big players from India like HCL, TCS, CTS, Infosys, Wipro, and Virtusa, and that's the main reason for this hatred and discussion.

毫无疑问，美国的H1b签证持有者做出了很大贡献。但印度的大公司，比如HCL、塔塔咨询、CTS、印孚瑟斯、威普罗和Virtusa滥用了这一制度，这就是导致这种仇恨和讨论的主要原因。

0 1 • Reply • Flag

The real issue is the illegal immigrants who do not work hard and live on subsidies, there by diverting the funds from development to revadis. Moreover,,they are responsible for most of the crimes further burdening the legal and police system.

真正的问题是非法移民，他们不努力工作，靠补贴生活。此外，他们对大多数罪行负有责任，进一步加重了司法和警察系统的负担。

9 1 • Reply • Flag

There is a phrase in Punjabi, " lakh di lanat" , even after being so much educated one has to do bootlicking of an uneducated, inexperienced, arrogant and good for nothing politician.

旁遮普语中有句话叫“lakh di lanat”，即使受过高等教育，一个人也不得不拍一个没受过教育、没有经验、傲慢、一无是处的政客的马屁。

12 13 • Reply • Flag

Your comment shows your love for Congress and Rahul Gandhi and hatred for Modi.

你的评论显示了你对国大党和拉胡尔·甘地的热爱，以及对莫迪的仇恨。

5 2 • Reply • Flag

you have commented in bad taste. Modi is knowledgeable. For a non technical person his knowledge and interest is above par in technical matters.

莫迪很有见识。对于一个非技术人员来说，他在技术方面的知识和兴趣是超水平的。

Drcarmocostaviegas

Opindia has got the situation correct . It is an anti Hindu sentiment. It's obviously brought about by Modi's BJP agenda which has tarnished our Hinduism everywhere. Everywhere.

这是一种反印度教的情绪。这显然是莫迪的人民党议程造成的，玷污了我们各地的印度教。

Vaanar Sainik

as usual another moronic comment

又是一条愚蠢的评论

Sanatani Clint Ew

Indians who were busy potraying them as the sole bread winners of US are now re evaluating their positions. Trumps new law to cancel citizenship to children of immigrants and the new wave (read Tsunami) of anti H1B protest by Americans are now intesnsifying. This is just the start of something very ugly. The violence is yet to start and that will be mark the real begining of MAGA. Indian who made memes of all CEOs being Indians and considered the whites and natives as inferior are the real people to blame. Jaisi karni waisi bharni. !!

印度人忙着把自己描绘成美国唯一的面包赢家，现在正在重新评估自己的立场。特朗普取消移民子女公民身份的新法律和美国人反H1B抗议的新浪潮正在加剧。这只是一些丑陋闹剧的开始。暴力还没有开始，这将标志着MAGA“美国再次伟大”的真正开始。印度人把所有首席执行官都说成是印度裔，认为白人和土著劣等，这才是真正的罪魁祸首。

Time

Looks like you want to spread mis information. What is cancel citizenship? There is no such thing going to happen in US.

看来你想散布错误的信息。什么取消公民权？美国不会发生这样的事情。

1 0 • Reply • Flag

mr clint sir , rural rust belt white americans are the real MAGA people who voted Trump to power 2 nd time !!!! . but the issue is these whites are blue collar workers who want high pay for lowest skilled jobs !!! those days are gone !!!

铁锈地带的美国白人是真正的MAGA，他们第二次投票给特朗普！但问题是，这些白人是蓝领工人，他们从事低技能工作却想要高薪！那些日子已经一去不复返了!

N Das

is my fav bjp running east india like company just focussing on private business centric economic growth. inside country there are enormous issues like privatized education, health care and real estate are cheating own country fellow. rich are getting rich and poor poorer

我最喜欢的人民党是像东印度公司一样经营印度，专注于以私营企业为中心的经济增长吗？在国内，有很多问题，比如私有化的教育、医疗保健和房地产正在欺骗自己的同胞。富人越来越富，穷人越来越穷

Sarcastic Bee

Dear MAGA supporters. Please don't oppose H1-B. The incompetent piece of $hit governing India right now is unable to generate employment. If you oppose H1-B, unemployed Indian youths would have no other option than joining SAFFRON TERROR ORGANIZATIONS like VHP, BAJRANG DAL, RSS etc. etc.

亲爱的MAGA支持者们。请不要反对H1-B。目前统治印度的那个无能的家伙无法创造就业。如果你反对H1-B签证，失业的印度年轻人将别无选择，只能加入像VHP、BAJRANG DAL、RSS等恐怖组织。

0 3 • Reply • Flag

India lost a great opportunity to become a developed nation due to poor and Unplanned governance by our 1st Congress PM after independence, Kindly read Below to Understand....,Congress Had imposed EMERGENCY on Nation for 21 months was a Blot on Democracy and Constitution thereby halting nations Growth and Development!,Dear Readers, Congress don't understand the damage they have done to the nation by kee indians largely Uneducated since Independence. if they had made a Education Compulsory and built schools and collage across India since 1947, we would have been a developed nation by 1975. They ruled with no vision for the Nation just for themselves and their families with rampant corruption and Nepotism.,Great initiative by present NDA Govt led by PM Modi Ji to transform our Country Into Viksit Bharat, a developed Nation by 2047, This is called Vision and Planning.

印度失去了成为发达国家的大好机会，原因是独立后第一任国大党总理太差了，将国家置于紧急状态长达21个月，这是皿煮和宪法的污点，阻碍了国家的增长和发展！自独立以来，国大党让印度人基本上没有受过教育，对国家造成了多大的伤害。如果他们从1947年开始实行义务教育，在印度各地建立学校和大学，我们到1975年就说不定已经成为发达国家了。他们统治国家没有远见，只为了自己和家族，腐败猖獗，裙带关系猖獗。莫迪总理领导的人民党政府提出了伟大的倡议，到2047年让我们的国家成为一个发达国家，这就是愿景和规划。

继续阅读：印度裔   裁员   美国   签证

此文由 三泰虎 编辑，未经允许不得转载！：首页 > 资讯 » 印媒：在美国的印度人也被裁员了，关于H-1B签证的争论存在分歧