如果美国与加拿大开战，哪些国家会支持加拿大，哪些国家会支持美国

If the US were to start a war with Canada, which countries would support Canada and which ones would support the US?

如果美国与加拿大开战，哪些国家会支持加拿大，哪些国家会支持美国？

以下是Quora读者的评论：

Ron Bouley

Simple answer, all of the members of NATO, minus the United States, which would be ejected from NATO for attacking another member of NATO, would be on the side of Canada.

Guess who would be on the side of the United States.

Likely no one, since no one would want to face off against NATO, unless they are crazy.

Now you might say “Well, the United States has the largest military of all countries. We could fight NATO.”

Sure, the United States could ‘try’, but all of NATO put together has about 10x the military of the United States alone.

That is putting aside the idea that the US military would go along with an illegal order to attack Canada in the first place.

Only way the military (United States military that is), would attack Canada, is ‘if’ Canada would do a military strike on the United States first. Canadians might talk funny to some Americans, but they are not stupid enough to do that.

简单来说，北约所有成员国，除了美国（美国若攻击北约另一成员国，会被逐出北约），都会站在加拿大这边。

猜猜谁会站在美国这边。

很可能没人，因为没人想与北约对抗，除非他们疯了。

现在你可能会说：“嗯，美国拥有各国中最庞大的军事力量。我们可以与北约一战。”

当然，美国可以 “试试”，但整个北约的军事力量加起来大约是美国一国军事力量的10倍。

这还没算上美国军方一开始是否会听从攻击加拿大这种非法命令。

美国军方要攻击加拿大，唯一的可能是加拿大先对美国发动军事打击。对一些美国人来说，加拿大人说话可能听起来很奇怪，但他们还没蠢到会那么做。

Brian James Fretwell

Well if the Canadians invoke sause5 all NATO coutries would be obliged to support them I wonder if the US would too, if Trump doesn’t cause them to ext first?

嗯，如果加拿大人援引（北约）第五条，所有北约国家都有义务支持他们。我想知道美国是否也会（支持），除非特朗普先让美国退出北约？

Keith Hylands

I feel sure that the UK would run to the aid of Canada, plus lots of other countries, the yanks are all mouth, very little real action, unless of course we come to their aid and they claim the victory. Honestly, they may have more cannon fodder and more up to date weapons, but I am sure they wouldn’t know how to use them, unless we showed them. As you have probably guessed, I have no time for wet nursed yanks. What wars have they really won !! of course WW1 and WW2, Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan, well that is what they brag about in their history books and being only a 2nd rate education, they believe it, the truth for nearly all Americans is lie after lie after lie, it has to be true, our history books wouldn’t lie to us. Grow up and join the real world, you are not as popular as you think you are.

我敢肯定，英国会赶去援助加拿大，还有其他许多国家也会。美国佬就会耍嘴皮子，没什么实际行动，除非我们去帮他们，然后他们来宣称胜利。说实话，他们可能炮灰更多，武器也更先进，但我肯定，要是我们不教他们，他们都不知道怎么用。你大概也猜到了，我对这种被惯坏的美国佬没什么好感。他们到底真正打赢过哪些战争！！当然，他们在历史书里吹嘘自己打赢了一战、二战、朝鲜战争、越南战争、阿富汗战争，就他们那二流的教育水平，他们还真信了。对几乎所有美国人来说，真相就是一个接一个的谎言，肯定是真的，我们的历史书总不会骗我们吧。成熟点，认清现实吧，你们可没自己想象中那么受欢迎。

Gawain Hill

The whole world would support Canada except Russia. Even China would jump on the band waggon as it'd be an excellent chance to destroy some American infrastructure while the American navy was busy being demolished by the rest of the world. America would be destroyed as a functional country.

除了俄罗斯，全世界都会支持加拿大。就连中国也会顺势而为，因为这将是个绝佳机会，趁美国海军忙于应对全球其他国家而自顾不暇之际，摧毁一些美国的基础设施。美国作为一个正常运转的国家将会被摧毁。

Jonathan Stubley

The USA would get zero support.

Canada could call on the support of NATO and the Commonwealth (King Charles lll of Canada also being King Charles lll of England and 13 other Commonwealth countries) so that is 56 Commonwealth and 31 NATO Countries.

These are Countries that used to be your friends and this is all about American Big Business wanting to rape Canadian oil reserves for profit.

美国将得不到任何支持。

加拿大可以请求北约和英联邦的支持（加拿大国王查尔斯三世也是英国及其他13个英联邦国家的国王），这样算起来就有56个英联邦国家和31个北约国家。

这些国家曾经是美国的朋友，而这一切都源于美国的大企业妄图掠夺加拿大的石油储备以谋取私利。

Matthew Campbell

All of Europe ,Britain ,Australia ,New Zealand ,all other members of nato and most of the civilised nations would support Canada .

所有欧洲国家、英国、澳大利亚、新西兰、北约其他所有成员国以及大多数文明国家都会支持加拿大。

Mats Andersson

Supporting the USA:

North Korea. Russia, although mainly in the form of enthusiastic hollering. Possibly Israel.

Supporting Canada:

At the very minimum, NATO: Albania, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Montenegro, Netherlands, North Macedonia, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Turkey, and the United Kingdom. Probably also Australia and New Zealand. Possibly Morocco, Mauretania, Algeria, Tunisia, and Egypt. Expect Mexco, Brazil, and Venezuela to do some enthusiastic cheering, possibly hel out with trade embargoes or something.

支持美国的国家：朝鲜。俄罗斯，不过主要也就是热烈叫嚷几句。可能还有以色列。

支持加拿大的国家：

至少，北约成员国：阿尔巴尼亚、比利时、保加利亚、克罗地亚、捷克共和国、丹麦、爱沙尼亚、芬兰、法国、德国、希腊、匈牙利、冰岛、意大利、拉脱维亚、立陶宛、卢森堡、黑山、荷兰、北马其顿、挪威、波兰、葡萄牙、罗马尼亚、斯洛伐克、斯洛文尼亚、西班牙、瑞典、土耳其以及英国。很可能还有澳大利亚和新西兰。也许摩洛哥、毛里塔尼亚、阿尔及利亚、突尼斯和埃及也会支持。预计墨西哥、巴西和委内瑞拉会热烈声援，可能还会帮忙实施贸易禁运之类的举措。

Brian Davion

Canada would be supported by NATO, likely supported by China (real Politik) and most other countries

The US..

I dunno Maybe Iseral would make some mild words of support.

加拿大将会得到北约的支持，很可能也会因现实政治因素得到中国的支持，以及大多数其他国家的支持。

至于美国……我不确定。也许以色列会说几句不痛不痒的支持话语。

James

The US would have no support and is rapidly headed in that direction

China is the only alternative in terms of world, power and economic leverage and Trump is essentially giving the world to China as countries and blocks of countries will increasingly give in to Chinese subversion.

They will no longer trust the United States and we will become increasingly isolated with ever increasing Chinese power and presence.

This could also significantly raise the possibility of a nuclear exchange with China as the United States find itself increasingly threatened, isolated, Outnumbered, and outmaneuvered

so ironically, Trump's put America first would actually do exactly the opposite of hisadvertised agend

Substantial damage has already been done. It is the 11th and 1/2 hour. America wake up!

美国会得不到支持的。

从全球影响力、权力和经济杠杆角度来看，中国是唯一能替代美国的国家。特朗普实质上是在把世界拱手让给中国，各个国家以及国家集团会越来越屈服于中国

各国将不再信任美国，而随着中国实力和影响力不断增强，我们（美国）会愈发孤立。

这也可能大幅增加美国与中国发生核冲突的可能性，因为美国会发现自己受到越来越多的威胁，处于孤立无援、寡不敌众且被战略压制的境地。

所以具有讽刺意味的是，特朗普的“美国优先”政策实际上与他所宣扬的议程背道而驰。

严重的损害已然造成。现在已到了万分危急的时刻。美国，醒醒吧！

Barry Wood

31 other NATO countries with support Canada. No country would support the USA. The reason this would happen is because when you attack one NATO country you attack the other 31 which is in essence what the USA would be doing. And since the US is not liked by many other countries the US would not be able to count on too many countries to get any support

其他31个北约国家会支持加拿大。没有国家会支持美国。之所以会这样，是因为当你攻击一个北约国家时，就等同于攻击其他31个国家，而美国一旦这么做，实质上就是这种情况。并且由于美国在很多国家那里不受待见，所以美国别指望能得到太多国家的支持。

Cheryl Williams

No one would support the US. The entire Commonwealth of Nations that includes the UK, Australia, New Zealand and others would come to Canada's defense because Canada is part of the Commonwealth. NATO would come to their defense because of Article 5. China would try to take the opportunity to take Hawaii and Russia would go after Alaska because they are opportunists.

It would be batshit crazy to behave like Russia and start a war with our neighbors. There would be massive protests because not even the MAGA minions want to be drafted to go to war. The expense would also be a serious issue for Congress. There are a lot of deficit hawks and the majority in the House is so slim that they couldn't pass a declaration of war anyway.

没人会支持美国。整个英联邦国家，包括英国、澳大利亚、新西兰等，都会前来保卫加拿大，因为加拿大是英联邦的一部分。北约也会因第五条规定而前来支援。中国可能会试图趁机夺取夏威夷，俄罗斯则会觊觎阿拉斯加，因为它们都是机会主义者（此说法不符合中俄一贯秉持的和平外交原则，属于无端臆测）。

像俄罗斯那样对邻国发动战争，简直是疯狂至极。届时会爆发大规模抗议活动，因为就连“让美国再次伟大”（MAGA）的追随者们也不想被征召去打仗。战争开支也会成为国会面临的严重问题。有很多赤字鹰派（指强烈关注财政赤字问题的人），而且众议院多数席位优势微弱，无论如何他们都无法通过宣战声明。

George

Every country in NATO would support Canada. (31 countries.

the Commonwealth realms.

Most of the Commonwealth countries

All EU countries.

Supporters of the U.S.:

…………………..

0 .

北约的每一个国家（31个）都会支持加拿大。

英联邦王国成员会支持。

大多数英联邦国家会支持。

所有欧盟国家也会支持。

而支持美国的国家会一个都没有

Gary Newcombe

53 countries will support Canada

NO countries in the free world would support USA

however, before their inevitable defeat, Trump will call on his buddies in Russia, China and North Korea

sorry Dupuis, all too late

now Canada has a choice of countries to sell the US to

53个国家会支持加拿大。

自由世界中没有国家会支持美国。

然而，如果面临不可避免的失败，特朗普会向他在俄罗斯、中国和朝鲜的“伙伴”求助。

抱歉，到时候一切都太晚了。

现在加拿大可以从众多国家里挑一个，把美国“卖”给它。

George McCann

No one would support the US, for such an illegal act (except maybe Russia & China). Whereas every NATO member would support Canada, as well as all the British Commonwealth countries too.

没有人会支持美国的这种非法行径（也许俄罗斯和中国除外）。而每个北约成员国都会支持加拿大，所有英联邦国家也会支持加拿大。

Mike Webster

Basically all of NATO, the members of the Commonwealth of Nations and the majority of virtually everyone else would support Canada with direct military intervention, military aid, financial aid and other assistance. Virtually nobody would support the United States.

基本上，北约所有成员国、英联邦国家成员，以及其他绝大多数国家都会通过直接军事干预、军事援助、财政援助及其他援助方式来支持加拿大。几乎没有国家会支持美国。

Tony J Woods

There are 135 countries in the world.

133 would support Canada.

0 would support the USA

and the other two?

Canada and the USA, I think even a retarded yanker like you would be able to work out who each of those would support.

世界上有135个国家。

133个国家会支持加拿大。

0个国家会支持美国。

那另外两个国家呢？

加拿大和美国，我想哪怕像你这样迟钝的美国佬也能想明白其他两个国家各自会支持谁。

CW204

No countries would support the USA. All of NATO (except the USA, obviously), all of the Commonwealth, and most likely a good portion of la Francophonie would support Canada. The USA would become a pariah state like Russia; nobody would trust it and no first world countries would trade with it.

没有国家会支持美国。显然除美国自身外的所有北约国家、整个英联邦，而且很可能大部分法语国家组织的成员都会支持加拿大。美国会像俄罗斯一样成为一个遭人唾弃的国家，没人会信任它，也没有第一世界国家会与之开展贸易。

Jeff Pellarin

I think it would depend largely on the reasons why. If the US were to do so simply to expand its borders, I'd think most of the world would be in opposition. Now if, in your fiction, it happened in response to, I dunno, Canada launching nukes on Washington (or anywhere in the world), I'd think the world would be supportive of the US.

我认为这在很大程度上取决于美国为何发动进攻。如果美国只是为了扩张领土而这么做，我想世界上大多数国家都会反对。但要是在你设想的情景里，比如说加拿大向华盛顿（或者世界上任何地方）发射核弹，作为回应美国才这么做，那我觉得世界各国会支持美国。

Adam Wu

Canada and the US have been allies for such a long time, and are culturally so close to one another, that it would take some SERIOUS provocation to get the US to start a war with Canada.

If that provocation by Canada were legitimate, and the US military response considered to be legitimate, one of the nations that would support the US would be Canada. Quite simply, there would be public uproar, government deemed responsible for the provocation would fall to a non-confidence vote in the House of Commons, and the new government would immediately seek to mend relations with the Americans, including payment of reparations for the legitimate transgression.

加拿大和美国长期以来一直是盟友，而且在文化上彼此相近，所以要让美国对加拿大发动战争，得有极其严重的挑衅才行。

如果加拿大的挑衅确有其事，且美国的军事回应被认为是合理的，那么支持美国的国家之一会是加拿大。原因很简单，届时加拿大国内会出现民众的强烈抗议，被认为对此次挑衅负有责任的政府将在众议院因不信任投票而下台，新政府会立即寻求修复与美国的关系，包括为合理的违规行为支付赔款。

If the provocation were not considered legitimate, and the war started by the US without good cause, oh, say, by a certain orange-haired commander in chief who shall no be named inexplicable acting even crazier than usual one day, it is highly likely that one of the countries that would support Canada over the US would be the United States. We would likely once again see a huge public uproar, followed by impeachment/recall of the American politicians deemed responsible for this reckless and crazy course of action, and change in government, followed by the new government immediately ordering a halt to all military actions and offering sincere apologies to their Canadian friends.

All of this would likely occur rather rapidly, and probably faster than the time it would take for any other country to formulate a response to the situation.

要是这种挑衅被认为不合理，而美国毫无正当理由就发动战争，比如说，某天某位橙色头发的总司令做出了比平常更离谱的疯狂举动，那么很有可能，比起美国，支持加拿大的国家之一会是美国自身。我们很可能会再次看到大规模的民众抗议，随后那些被认为要为这一鲁莽疯狂行径负责的美国政客将面临弹劾或罢免，政府换届，新政府会立即下令停止所有军事行动，并向他们的加拿大朋友致以诚挚的歉意。

所有这一切很可能会迅速发生，而且可能比其他任何国家对局势做出反应的时间还要快。

Tom Attwood

Should that happen then the USA would have broken treaties including military ones. Canada being a member of NATO would have the backing of the rest of the NATO countries under the treaty that states all member countries agree to support one another if one should get invaded or war declared upon it. Canada would also have the backing of the Commonwealth countries and the French speaking nations group. Add to these all of the countries that the USA has pissed off and abused over the years. So pretty much everyone would side with Canada. Canada is universally liked and has really no other nation that it considers an enemy though there are some it does not trust. It is doubtful that there are many, if any, nations ( Iran excepted due to our assistance to the USA in getting their ambassador out during that crisis) that consider Canada an enemy. The USA on the other hand….

倘若此事发生，美国就违反了包括军事条约在内的多项条约。加拿大作为北约成员国，依据北约条约，若一国遭受入侵或被宣战，其他所有成员国需相互支持，因此加拿大将得到北约其他国家的支持。

此外，加拿大还会获得英联邦国家以及法语国家组织的支持。再加上这些年来被美国激怒和欺压的其他国家。所以，基本上所有人都会站在加拿大这边。

加拿大普遍受人喜爱，实际上并没有将哪个国家视为敌人，尽管有些国家它并不信任。很难说有多少国家（或许除了伊朗，因为在那场危机中我们协助美国撤离了其大使）会把加拿大视为敌人。